We are worried that the Government will seize upon the Supreme Court’s latest utterances
We ask with some anxiety. The Central Government has a gift, and the gift is listening. It listens to the Supreme Court very closely. In 2018, in Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, the Supreme Court allowed that a protest near the seat of power may be more effective than one held far away — “this may be correct,” it said — and then added, in the same breath, that we live in an era of technology in which a concerned voice can reach the right quarters by numerous means, WhatsApp, Twitter and Instagram among them. The Court meant the first half, and said so: it kept Jantar Mantar open for regulated protests. The Government heard the second. On 11 October the Delhi Police struck Jantar Mantar off the list of protest sites and, for consolation, identified three alternative venues.
On Thursday the Court issued notice. Counsel pointed out that the order described itself as passed in terms of a Supreme Court order. The Solicitor General said the Court’s order was not the basis: a committee had met, a report had been written, reasons had been recorded.
Then Hon’ble Justice Bagchi handed the Government a fresh set of words. The word “heard”, he observed, must now be understood from the perspective of technology also. The Government will have taken that down. We wish it had not.
Because the logic travels, and we cannot find where it stops. If a protester need not be near the Government to be heard, a judge need not be near the Government to be obeyed. We have read Article 130: the Court sits in Delhi “or in such other place or places, as the Chief Justice of India may, with the approval of the President, from time to time, appoint.” So we expect a committee. We expect a report. We expect recorded reasons and a Standing Order denotifying Tilak Marg “in terms of the observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.” The Solicitor General will deny that the observations were the basis. The Court will issue notice.
We asked two colleagues where the Court might be sent, hoping to be told we were being silly. Neither said so. One suggested Mirzapur. The other said he hoped it was a real town and not a fictional one, because if the Centre moved the Supreme Court to a fictional town, given all the difficulties we face today, the Court might be in limbo for a very long time. We have checked, and are relieved that Mirzapur is real: a district headquarters in Uttar Pradesh, on the Ganga, some 700 km from Tilak Marg. It weaves carpets for the world, so the Court will not go short of a red one. A web series has lately made its name synonymous with the question of who really runs the town — a question the Supreme Court is well placed to adjudicate. And whatever the mobile coverage there, the Court has now held that it is enough to be heard.
Our friends at the Bar tell us not to worry: the Court will stay the move. We would like to believe them, but this Court does not stay this Government’s orders and laws; it issues notice. Close to a lakh litigants file in the Supreme Court each year, and we are worried that, when the stay comes up, the Central Government will argue that if 22 lakh voters can wait for the next election, a lakh litigants can wait to come back to New Delhi; that nothing is lost in the meantime, since the Court will sit in Mirzapur, or wherever it is sent, and they can file there, argue there and litigate there — including the challenge to the move itself; and that once that appeal is decided, everything can come back to New Delhi. The right to vote is, after all, far more important than the right to file. We are worried that the Supreme Court might find it impossible to disagree.