Dear Colleagues,
Yesterday, the Delhi Police detained advocates who were protesting near the Supreme Court. By some accounts, about a hundred were taken away to the Yamuna Sports Complex. The Supreme Court Bar Association has condemned the excessive force used on them, and on women advocates in particular. They were released the same day, after the Chief Justice of India spoke to the authorities.
The expected advice will now follow. Move the Court. Demand action against the officers. Claim compensation. I offer different counsel. Spare the Supreme Court. Go back to the street, and turn the other cheek.
I do not say this in despair. I say it because we have seen what happens when a free people asks its highest court to stand between it and a determined executive, and the Supreme Court will not.
On 25 June 1975, thirteen days after the Allahabad High Court set aside her election, Smt. Indira Gandhi had the President proclaim an Emergency on the ground of “internal disturbance”. The Shah Commission later found no crisis of law and order. No intelligence report before the Proclamation spoke of one. The Home Secretary, the Cabinet Secretary, the Director of the Intelligence Bureau and the Law Minister learnt of the Emergency the next morning. More than one lakh Indians were then arrested or detained under MISA and the Defence of India Rules.
The detenus went to the High Courts. As many as nine of them, the Karnataka High Court among them, held that a citizen could still ask for habeas corpus. The Union carried the question to the Supreme Court. On 28 April 1976, in ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla, four of the five judges reversed them all. The Attorney General had conceded before the Bench that if a police officer shot a man dead out of personal enmity, there would be no remedy so long as the Emergency lasted. The majority would not let any court question whether a detention had anything to do with the “internal disturbance”, real or a bogey. It shut the door.
Weigh that against an older case. In 1772, James Somerset, an enslaved African, lay shackled on a ship in the Thames, bound for Jamaica to be sold. His friends applied to the Court of King’s Bench. Lord Mansfield issued habeas corpus and, on 22 June 1772, set him free. Two hundred years later, a citizen of the Republic of India could not get the writ that a slave in London had got. That is what our Supreme Court gave us.
Advocates who keep taking critical challenges to the Modi administration to the Supreme Court refuse to see what the Court is doing with the questions they bring.
Take the Special Intensive Revision of the electoral rolls. A revision is needed. Only a fool would say otherwise. Rolls collect the dead, the departed and the duplicated, and a democracy must clear them out. But a revision is only as honest as its standard. On what basis does the Election Commission decide that a voter must go? On what basis does it single out a voter and call upon him, even prima facie, to explain why he should not be struck off? These are the first questions any court should ask. None of the Supreme Court orders I have read required the Commission to state the actual standard by which it strikes off a given name, or tested whether that standard was a constitutionally acceptable method of taking away a citizen’s vote.
In West Bengal, over 27 lakh names were struck off after adjudication. Days before the April polls, the Supreme Court held that the mere pendency of an appeal gave no one the right to vote. Those whose appeals were still pending could not vote. Lakhs of citizens who were on the roll at the last election were struck off on the eve of this one and shut out of the poll. If that does not shock the conscience of the Supreme Court, the citizen may fairly ask what that conscience is for.
A right to vote that revives after the votes are counted is not a right. It is a condolence. Our election law lets the Election Commission order a special revision at any time, and freezes the roll only from the last date for nominations. It gives a voter missing from the list no provisional ballot. With no safeguard in the statute, a court that guards democracy had one obvious protection to offer: hold back mass deletions on the eve of a poll. A doctrine that removes the vote first and hears the appeal later has no place in a court that sits over the largest democracy on earth.
A careful reader will stop me here. The SIR, he will say, is not the work of the Modi administration. It is the work of the Election Commission of India, an independent constitutional body. I stand corrected. I also know this because the Modi administration tells us so, often.
The Supreme Court, of course, has the final word on all of this. But nothing in the Constitution says it will decide correctly. Article 141 says only that the law it declares binds every court in India. That law commands our obedience and deserves our respect. It does not promise to be right. Justice Robert Jackson of the American Supreme Court confessed as much of his own court: it was final, he said, not necessarily correct. At times, that is reason enough to spare ours. A wrong answer from a final court is not merely wrong. It is binding.
So I say to my colleagues who were detained yesterday: do not hand the Supreme Court another critical question about the Modi administration’s power. Spare the Supreme Court the occasion. Spare the Constitution the precedent. Go instead to the protest. Stand there in your bands. If the lathi falls, turn the other cheek. That counsel comes from the Sermon on the Mount, and Mahatma Gandhi turned it into a method of national struggle. It is not submission. A blow returned ends the argument. A blow absorbed begins one, and the nation will judge it. Non-violence asks nothing of a judge. It asks the conscience of the people, whose verdict no bench can overrule.