In 1932 Satyavati, the 26-year-old granddaughter of Swami Shraddhanand, went to jail for two years for taking women out in procession through the streets of Delhi, where the Congress was outlawed and assembly banned. This Wednesday, in Delhi, a Special Executive Magistrate sent two leaders of the Cockroach Janta Party to Tihar for five days for walking into Jantar Mantar the day after a police order closed it. Ninety-four years apart.
For three-quarters of a century we have had a Constitution, and to enforce it against the executive we built a judiciary the executive does not choose. The judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts are, in practice, picked by judges; the Government and the President sign what the collegium sends them. No other democracy has gone that far to keep the bench out of the executive's hands. With such a Constitution and our judiciary, what has really changed in a hundred years for the citizen at the barricade?
Satyavati led the women's wing of the Delhi Congress through the civil disobedience of 1930–32. She and her volunteers made salt in breach of the salt law and handed it out in public, picketed shops selling foreign cloth, and led processions in defiance of prohibitory orders. The Government's instruments were the Code of 1898: a magistrate's order under Section 144 forbidding assembly; trial before a magistrate who belonged to the executive; and, as the price of liberty, a bond under Chapter VIII to keep the peace and stay out of politics. The published accounts say she was sentenced in 1932, contracted pleurisy and tuberculosis in jail, was offered release against the bond, and refused it. She died in 1945, aged 39.
Now the 2026 file. Last week, CJP leaders were detained inside an aircraft as it landed in Delhi, where Section 163 BNSS — Section 144 renumbered — ran four kilometres around Jantar Mantar. A Special Executive Magistrate released them on a bond to keep the peace for a year. On Sunday the Supreme Court sat specially and directed that peaceful assembly "shall be permitted in accordance with law"; the same day the Commissioner of Police signed a Standing Order striking Jantar Mantar, the centre of that zone, off as the designated site. On Monday two CJP leaders asked Parliament Street police station for a date. On Tuesday they climbed the barricade at the Jantar Mantar with the national flag. On Wednesday the Special Executive Magistrate — an officer of the executive — remanded them for five days; the police call it a breach of the bond and a repeat breach of Section 163.
I will not recite what has changed on paper. The judgments sit in every law report. I would rather invite the leading lawyers of India to tell the people of this country what has really changed on the ground.