The ongoing Jana Nayagan certification controversy has been framed as a battle between a film star and the censor board, or worse, as a political slugfest between Tamil Nadu and Delhi. Both framings miss the point entirely.
The real story is this: India’s film certification body appears to have forgotten the fundamental nature of what it grants. And that should concern filmmakers, producers, artists, and of course, the audience who watch movies.
A CERTIFICATE IS NOT A LEASE
When the government grants a mining lease, it parts with a valuable natural resource. The State has an ongoing interest in how that resource is exploited. It can impose conditions. It can monitor compliance. It can revoke the lease for breach. The relationship between the State and the lessee is continuous and supervisory.
A film certificate is nothing like this.
When the CBFC certifies a film, it is not granting a favour. It is not parting with a scarce resource. It is not entering into an ongoing relationship with the filmmaker. It is simply performing a statutory function: examining whether the film violates any of the narrow restrictions in Section 5B of the Cinematograph Act and, if not, issuing a certificate confirming that the film may be publicly exhibited.
The CBFC’s conduct in the Jana Nayagan case suggests that it views certification as something it can grant, withhold, reconsider, and withdraw at pleasure—as if it were administering mining leases in Bellary rather than certifying films in Chennai. This confusion is dangerous.
THE STATUTORY PROCESS — AND HOW IT WAS BROKEN
The Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 establish a clear, sequential process:
- Producer applies for certification.
- Regional Officer refers the film to an Examining Committee.
- Examining Committee views the film and records recommendations in Form VIII.
- The Board (through the Chairperson) takes action in conformity with the recommendation.
- The decision is communicated to the producer.
- If excisions are required, the producer carries them out and submits Form IX.
- The Regional Officer verifies the excisions.
- The certificate is issued.
The Chairperson has a limited intervention power under Rule 25. He may refer the film to a Revising Committee either on his own motion or on the producer’s request. But this power exists only at Step 4 — before the Board takes action in conformity with the Examining Committee’s recommendation.
In the Jana Nayagan case:
- The Board completed Step 4 on 22nd December 2025.
- The communication was sent the same day (Step 5).
- The producer submitted excisions on 24th December (Step 6).
- A Committee member verified them the same day (Step 7).
The only thing remaining was Step 8 — issuance of the certificate.
Instead, on 5th January 2026, the Chairperson purported to invoke Rule 25 and refer the film to a Revising Committee. This was not merely irregular. It was, as the learned Single Judge of the Hon’ble Madras High Court held, “without jurisdiction.”
THE COMPLAINT THAT STARTED IT ALL
The trigger for this entire controversy was a complaint by an Advisory Panel Member who was part of the Examining Committee.
He had watched the film on 19th December 2025. (Step 2)
He had written and signed his recommendations in Form VIII. (Step 3)
His objections had been accepted and implemented through excisions. (Step 7)
After all this, he suddenly wrote to the CBFC claiming that “the film has been approved without following due procedure” and that his objections were ignored.
The learned Single Judge of the Madras High Court compared this complaint with the complainant’s own Form VIII and found that the objections he raised had, in fact, already been addressed. His complaint was found to be “an afterthought” that “appears motivated.”
Yet it was on the basis of this very complaint — from a person who had already completed his role— that the CBFC Chairperson chose to resurrect powers that had already been exhausted.
THE DIVISION BENCH INTERIM STAY
Before the Hon’ble Division Bench, the CBFC urged for a stay on these grounds:
Ground 1: “The appellants were not granted sufficient opportunity”
The Additional Solicitor General had made elaborate submissions before the Single Judge. The original CBFC files were produced. The complaint and the Form VIII were examined. The ASGI confirmed on instructions that the Chairperson’s action was based solely on the complaint.
The issue was purely legal:
Did the Chairperson have jurisdiction to act after 22nd December?
No amount of further time could have changed that.
More troubling still, the CBFC had all of Thursday to move the Division Bench before judgment was delivered on Friday. It chose to remain silent — and then complained of urgency only after it lost.
Ground 2: “The order was set aside without certiorari”
This elevates form over substance.
The Single Judge relied on binding Supreme Court authority holding that orders passed without jurisdiction are nullities and need not be separately quashed before mandamus is issued. Justice cannot be sacrificed at the altar of technicalities.
To insist on a separate certiorari for a void order would mean that litigants must pre-emptively challenge every illegal act that a statutory authority might improvise mid-litigation.
That is not the law.
Ground 3: “No certification was granted”
The producer’s grievance was precisely that certification was being unlawfully withheld.
Under Rule 37(6) of the 2024 Rules:
“In cases where the film is not referred to a Revising Committee, a certificate shall be issued within two days.”
The Single Judge held that the so-called referral to a Revising Committee was without jurisdiction. Therefore, the statutory two-day clock applied. The certificate was overdue by nearly two weeks.
The absence of a certificate was not a defense.
It was the very reason the mandamus was issued.
A REGULATOR THAT HAS LOST ITS WAY
Film certification exists to balance free expression with the limited restrictions of Article 19(2). It does not exist to give bureaucrats an indefinite veto over creative work. It does not exist to permit politically timed interventions. It does not exist to be weaponised through motivated complaints from those who have already approved the film.
The CBFC must decide what it is.
Is it a certification body that applies the law and then steps aside?
Or is it a licensing authority that treats every certificate as a revocable favour?
If it is the former, then once the statutory process is complete, the certificate must issue — because the right to exhibit a film is a constitutional entitlement, not a government indulgence.
If it is the latter, let Parliament and the Courts decide the place of body in a constitutional democracy.
Disclaimer: I have no connection to this film or to people involved in this film.