Bengaluru: The events at Karnataka Legislature's Joint Session today have generated significant public debate and constitutional confusion. Hon'ble Governor Sri Thaawarchand Gehlot's two-line address drew attention when he concluded his customary address after reading just two opening lines, despite a longer government-prepared speech, before walking out. As a lawyer, I wish to clarify what the Constitution actually provides.
The Westminster Tradition
The Governor's Address is drawn from Westminster parliamentary tradition. In the British Parliament, the King's Speech is written entirely by the Government and outlines its legislative agenda. The Monarch reads it as prepared—without alteration or objection. No British Monarch has ever refused to read or edited the speech based on personal disagreement. Our Constitution adopted this tradition. The Governor's role is to read, not to review; to deliver, not to dissent.
What Does the Constitution Say?
Article 176 mandates that the Governor shall address the Legislature at the commencement of the first session each year. The Governor's speech is a declaration of the government's policies—prepared by the cabinet. The Governor reads the speech, but it is not the Governor's speech. The Governor has no authority to edit, omit, or substitute portions of the Address.
Why the Governor Has No Basis to Object
The speech is delivered in a Legislature where freedom of speech is almost absolute. Article 194 guarantees freedom of speech in State Legislatures—no address can be questioned in any court for anything said within. The Governor's Address forms part of House proceedings and enjoys parliamentary privilege.
If elected members can criticise Central Government policies with absolute freedom, on what basis can the Governor refuse to read a speech containing similar criticism? There is none. The Governor is not a gatekeeper of permissible speech—assuming the role of censor fundamentally misunderstands the office of the Governor.
States Can Constitutionally Disagree With Central Laws
The Constitution permits States to disagree with Central legislation on Concurrent List subjects, enact their own laws, and seek Presidential assent for such laws to prevail. If the Constitution allows States to change Central laws within their territory, how can a Governor refuse to even read a speech criticising that law? The Governor's personal agreement is constitutionally improper.
Similarly, Legislatures may pass resolutions extending beyond strict legislative competence—resolutions may be political and criticise Central Government policy. The Governor is expected to read out the State's agenda, even if it criticises the Centre. No veto over legislative discussion exists in our Constitution.
Legislative Business Remains Valid
Some claim today's legislative business is constitutionally void. This has no basis. What occurred is an irregularity, not a jurisdictional defect. Article 212 states: "The validity of any proceedings in the Legislature of a State shall not be called in question on the ground of any alleged irregularity of procedure." Further legislative business would be constitutionally valid.
The Governor Cannot Be Excluded
Those suggesting States bypass the Governor misunderstand our Constitution. Article 174(1) provides that the Governor shall summon the Legislature—this is the exclusive mechanism by which sessions commence. Without the Governor's gazette notification, there is no session. Today's session itself occurred because the Governor issued a notification to summon and commence today’s session. The Governor is indispensable to our constitutional machinery.
A Historical Perspective
One would be tempted to blame the BJP and sympathise with opposition-ruled States—if one ignores history. Tensions between Governors and State Governments are not new. Such friction occurred under previous Central governments too. Viewing today's events as a continuation of long-standing institutional malaise—rather than political suppression—may bring us closer to durable solutions.
Political Theatre on Both Sides
Equally, it would be naive to assume that the Karnataka's Government was surprised. The State was aware of the Governor's objections and likely response. By preparing the speech in the manner it did, the State Government made a calculated choice to generate national headlines and energise its narrative against the Centre. While constitutional impropriety lies with the Governor, the political spectacle was co-authored by the Governor and the State Government.
Our democracy's strength lies in all institutions functioning within their boundaries with mutual respect.