The deferment of the Indian release of Billie Eilish – Hit Me Hard and Soft: The Tour (Live in 3D) is the occasion for this statement, but it is not its reason. No single film, however prominent, can be the basis on which a country reorganises a constitutional regime of speech. The reason to end film censorship in India is older and deeper. It lies in the Constitution itself, in the maturity of the Indian audience, and in the absurdity of a system that trusts citizens to read but not to watch. The Billie Eilish episode merely makes that absurdity visible to a generation that had stopped noticing it.

The film was scheduled to open in Indian theatres on 8 May 2026. It is reported that the release was pushed back after the Central Board of Film Certification sought multiple cuts. The film is described as a concert feature co-directed by Billie Eilish and James Cameron of Avatar fame.

Why this audience matters

Billie Eilish is among the most followed international artists in India today. Her music has lived for years on the playlists of Indian teenagers, students and young professionals. Her introspective music has shaped how an entire generation of young Indians thinks about voice and mood. For a great many Indians under thirty, she is part of the soundtrack of growing up.

Crores of those young Indians, who consume her work on phones the State does not pre-approve and platforms the State does not pre-clear, were told that a filmed record of her concert required a Board's supervisory hand before it could appear on a theatrical screen. Laugh?

The double standard between print and screen

India does not pre-censor books. No novelist files a manuscript with a board. No historian seeks an advance permit. No journalist clears a column with a censor. And yet the Republic has not collapsed. India has lived through pamphlets, polemics, satire and disagreement of every shade. The reading citizen has been trusted. The viewing citizen has not. If the printed word travels without prior certification, on what principle is the moving image singled out?

An old judgment in a new world

The legal foundation of film pre-censorship is K. A. Abbas v. Union of India, in which the Supreme Court held that cinema, by virtue of its emotional immediacy, could be subjected to prior restraint. That ruling reflected its time. It was written before satellite television, the smartphone, social media, OTT and the global simultaneous release. The premise that film is uniquely powerful, and therefore uniquely dangerous, cannot bear that weight today, when every adult carries an unfiltered screen in a pocket.

Classification, not censorship

What India needs is not a board that cuts. It needs a body that informs. Classification tells the audience what a film contains and which age group it suits. It does not empower the State to slice, dilute, postpone or politically smooth a film. Classification trusts the viewer; censorship suspects the viewer. Classification offers information; censorship imposes control.

The two films that expose the system

Nothing illustrates the arbitrariness of Indian film certification today better than placing two recent cases side by side.

Jana Nayagan, starring actor Vijay who is now the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, ran into trouble with the CBFC over content that must appear laughable when set against the content of the hugely successful Dhurandhar films. The producers of Jana Nayagan had announced a Pongal release on 13 January, in keeping with Tamil cinema's festival tradition. The CBFC's objections, when they arrived, were this: a displeasure with the producers having announced the release date in advance, and a discomfort with the film's content — which involved foreign powers fomenting religious discontent in India, and references to the Army. Indian cinema has dramatised invasions, insurgencies, terror networks and intelligence operations for decades. To treat such themes, in 2026, as objects of pre-censorial alarm is laughable.

Now consider Dhurandhar: The Revenge. The CBFC's record shows an 'A' certificate on 17 March 2026 for a 19 March 2026 release (announced months in advance) - after a few modifications to violent visuals, abusive language and disclaimers. Dhurandhar pushes past what the censoring body has historically tolerated. It was certified. It released. It earned.

Dhurandhar deserved to release the way it was made. The point is narrower: if Dhurandhar could be cleared, the objections raised against Jana Nayagan appear, by comparison, laughable. They cannot be reconciled on any neutral standard. What reconciles them is the political comfort of the certifier. Dhurandhar moves with the establishment's preferred national narrative; the CBFC is staffed by appointees of that establishment. When the certifier is appointed by the Executive, the certifier's instincts come to resemble the Executive's. That is not certification. It is selection by the State.

The market has already answered

A great many Indian films are bombing at the box office. Audiences are walking away from caution and from product made under the long shadow of what the Board might think. Dhurandhar Part 1 and Part 2 thrived because they were willing to be bold and the certifier did not stand in their way. The lesson is that the Indian audience has matured well past the Indian certification regime. A viewer who has spent the week on unfiltered global and OTT content will not pay for a hesitant, second-guessed film on the weekend in movie theatres. The market is voting against censorship. The law has not caught up.

Abbas can be revisited

The K. A. Abbas judgment is not scripture. The Supreme Court has, on more than one occasion, reopened larger questions when constitutional understanding has shifted or when the conditions on which an earlier ruling rested have changed.

The Sabarimala matter offers a recent and instructive example. In 2018, a Constitution Bench of five judges held, by majority, that the practice of excluding menstruating women from entry into the Sabarimala temple was unconstitutional, and permitted entry to women of all ages. That decision was contested through review and writ petitions, and in 2019 a five-judge Bench took the unusual step of referring a set of broader questions to a nine-judge Bench for re-consideration.That nine-judge Bench is currently deliberating the issue.

The same logic applies, with even greater force, to film censorship. K. A. Abbas was decided in 1970, in a media universe that no longer exists. It rested on factual assumptions about the unique influence of cinema, the limited alternative channels of expression, and the protective role of the State in shaping public taste — assumptions that the smartphone, the streaming service and the global simultaneous release have demolished. The creative community should approach the Supreme Court to ask it reconsider whether prior restraint on cinema continues to satisfy the Constitution in an era in which every other form of expression operates without it.

The question, simply put

The argument is not that India should abandon censorship lightly. It is that India should abandon censorship because the Constitution, the audience, the technology and the market have all moved beyond it — and this delay is simply the latest demonstration of that fact.

Signed PDF of this piece

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India