To
Shri Narendra Modi
The Hon'ble Prime Minister of India
New Delhi – 110 011

Subject: India Must Speak Now — a) The Massacre in Iran, b) the Lawlessness of "Operation Epic Fury," c) the Bankruptcy of Regime Change by Air Strikes, and d) Why India's Silence Could Cost Us Too Much

Respected Prime Minister

I write as an Advocate— trained to test propositions against the standards of law and evidence, and to weigh arguments by the gravity of its consequences.

Over the years, I have written to successive Prime Ministers of India on matters of great public interest — on questions of constitutional principle and on failures of governance that the law demands be named. These letters have been written after deliberation, in the tradition of an independent bar that has always understood its duty to extend beyond the courtroom.

THE DEAD SCHOOLGIRLS

Let us begin with the human truth from which every other consideration must draw its moral weight.

On February 28, 2026, Israel and the United States launched a joint attack on various targets in Iran. The operation is codenamed "Roaring Lion" by Israel and "Operation Epic Fury" by the United States Department of Defence. The goal: regime change in Iran.

At around 17:30 CET of the first day of strikes alone, the Red Crescent reported that 201 civilians had been killed and 747 injured in Iran. But that is merely the opening entry of an accounting that is not yet complete.

Israeli strikes targeted a girls' school in the southern city of Minab and killed at least one hundred schoolgirls. The airstrikes hit on the first day of Iran's work week, while many were at work or in school.

This is not collateral damage. And it did not fall from the sky in isolation. The Iranian government had itself responded to domestic protests with violent repression, including massacres of protesters, with the deadliest incidents occurring on January 8 and 10, 2026; the US-based Human Rights Activists News Agency estimated the death toll at 7,000, though estimates varied widely — from the Iranian government's figure of 3,117 to claims exceeding 12,000. The Iranian regime's slaughter of thousands of its own protesters is a crime against its own people that deserves the world's unequivocal condemnation.

The Iranian people were therefore being killed by their own government earlier and now, by foreign bombs. The world's largest democracy cannot be the nation that looks away from both.

Prime Minister, history will ask what India said when schoolgirls were being buried under rubble in Minab. Let the answer, when history asks, not be silence.

It must be said, however, that the death of Ayatollah Khamenei, a man who presided over decades of theocratic repression and ordered the massacre of thousands of his own citizens just weeks before his end, is no cause for mourning.

A PROMISE THAT BECAME A PROVOCATION

Before examining whether this war is legal, we must examine whether it is honest.

Only a few days after the protests in Iran began, Mr. Trump promised that the United States of America would go to their rescue if the Iranian government killed protesters. Mr. Trump continued to promise that he was planning something, saying "help is on the way," and demanding protesters "take over institutions". Trump set a redline, warning the Iranian regime not to kill protesters. The clerics ignored the redline and massacred thousands of their own people anyway.

Those who encouraged the protesters to take to the streets with the words "help is on the way" — and afterwards delivered bombs that fell on their schools — bear a share of moral and political responsibility for what is happening to the people of Iran.

THIS WAR IS UNLAWFUL — THE LAW IS NOT AMBIGUOUS

I am bound to examine the legal justification for these strikes before condemning them. Having examined it carefully, I find no legal case at all.

The UN Charter reads in Article 2(4): "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the purposes of the United Nations."

Article 2(4) has been described as the cornerstone of the UN Charter and one of the foundations of the modern international legal order.

The permissible exceptions are precisely two: a Security Council mandate under Chapter VII, or self-defence under Article 51 when an armed attack has occurred and the response is necessary and proportionate.

No Security Council resolution authorised these strikes. Not one. Customary international law recognises the right of anticipatory self-defence only when an armed attack is imminent and inevitable. If an attack is possible but not imminent, a state is not justified in launching a pre-emptive strike.

Crucially, there was no imminent attack. From February 6, 2026, Iran and the US had been in indirect nuclear negotiations mediated by Oman, and technical nuclear talks were scheduled to continue in Vienna. Tehran had been in the middle of diplomatic negotiations with the US aimed at preventing war when it was hit and called for the UN Security Council to meet immediately to discuss the attacks.

Oman's Foreign Minister, who mediated the US-Iran indirect talks, flew to Washington on Friday to brief US officials, saying he believed they had made progress in the negotiations — only for war to break out on Saturday morning.

Secretary-General Guterres reiterated his condemnation of the US and Israeli airstrikes for violating Iran's sovereignty and territorial integrity and international law, including the UN Charter. Critics of the strikes have also called them illegal under domestic and international law.

This is not a contested grey area in law. This is a named and Secretary-General-acknowledged violation of the foundational charter of the international order — a charter that India helped draft and sign as one of the original member nations of the United Nations in 1945. India's silence on this violation is not neutrality. It is abdication.

THE STRATEGIC THEORY IS AS BANKRUPT AS THE CASINOS

Having established that this war is unlawful, let us now examine whether it will achieve its declared purpose. The evidence is overwhelming — and conclusively says it will not.

Mr. Trump declared that the objective was to destroy Iran's missile and military capabilities, prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons, and ultimately topple the regime.

"Operation Epic Fury" will be "massive and ongoing," President Trump said.

Commentators in the United States are already raising a fundamental question about the strategic judgement of the architect of this gamble. Trump’s hotels and casino businesses have declared chapter 11 bankruptcy four times, due to their inability to meet required payments and to re-negotiate debt with banks, owners of stock and bonds, and various small businesses.

According to a Temple University study, Trump's casinos also lost more money than their competitors and went through more bankruptcies than any other major business in America.

A man who drove the most naturally profitable industry in America — the gambling business — into repeated insolvency by making rosy projections, underestimating costs, and shifting the burden of failure to others, is now applying the same instincts to a war against a civilisation of 93 million people. The pattern is consistent: grand promises at the outset, catastrophic miscalculation in execution, and the costs of failure borne by those least able to pay them.

Regime changes pursued through military air campaigns have failed miserably — and left behind wreckage far worse, and far more dangerous, than anything the politicians promised when asking for support to go to war. Note however, that the United States Congress has not authorised this war – as mandated by their Constitution. A broader historical and social lens reveals a clear pattern: foreign-imposed regime-change operations produce insecurity, undermine democracy, and often have tragic humanitarian outcomes.

And there is a far more recent, and far more instructive, precedent — one that unfolded just months ago, in this same theatre, under this same President. President Trump's fight against the Houthis never dealt a crippling blow to the militant group. US airstrikes on Yemen fell short of degrading the Houthis' military capabilities and in fact strengthened their domestic and regional propaganda.

Concerning Iran, initiating a major war with a nation of 93 million people, 2,500 years of history, significant retaliatory capabilities, and no clear opposition within the country is a significant risk. History lacks good examples of air campaigns that have easily toppled regimes and led to replacements that the attackers preferred.

THE NUMBERS INDIA CANNOT AFFORD TO IGNORE

India's reliance on imported crude oil has increased to 88.6% as domestic production has declined. In Financial Year 2024–25, India spent approximately $137 billion — roughly ₹11.44 lakh crore— solely to import crude oil. This is not money that builds hospitals, funds schools, or creates employment. It is sovereign wealth permanently transferred to the treasuries of foreign nations, many of which are now active theatres of war.

To feel the true weight of this number, translate it into the governance of our own states. Tamil Nadu's total revenue receipts for 2025-26 are estimated to be ₹3,31,569 crore — for a state of 8 crore people that is the powerhouse of India's manufacturing, exports, and automobile industry.

Karnataka's receipts, excluding borrowings, for 2025-26 are estimated to be ₹2,92,647 crore— the state that hosts India's technology capital and drives a significant share of our software exports.

Uttar Pradesh, our most populous state governing over 24 crore citizens, has budgeted revenue receipts of approximately ₹6.63 lakh crore for FY26.

Together, the revenues of Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, and Karnataka — three states that collectively govern nearly 38 crore Indians — amount to approximately ₹12.87 lakh crore. India's annual crude oil import bill of ₹11.44 lakh crore nearly matches this combined figure. It is almost double the entire annual revenues of Uttar Pradesh alone. It is more than three times the annual revenues of Tamil Nadu. It is nearly four times the annual revenues of Karnataka. Every rupee of it leaves India permanently, every year, paid to nations now engulfed in conflict.

Now consider what a single escalation does to this already staggering bill. As per ICRA's calculations, a $10 per barrel uptick in the average crude oil price for a fiscal year pushes up net oil imports by $12–13 billion during the year, thereby enlarging the current account deficit by 0.3% of GDP.

A $10 rise in crude prices — the kind of shock a single week of sustained conflict in the Strait of Hormuz can trigger — would add the equivalent of nearly Kerala's entire annual revenue receipts to India's oil import bill in a single year. Kerala's budget estimates for 2025-26 show revenue receipts of ₹1,52,351.67 crore — the full annual budget of a state of 3.5 crore people, celebrated for its human development, literacy, and healthcare. That is what one $10 price spike costs India, additionally, in a single year. And India imports oil from Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and the UAE, as well as liquefied natural gas from Qatar, through the Strait of Hormuz — a narrow sea passage that is now directly in the theatre of this war.

The conflict has already damaged air hubs, rocked densely populated areas, and disrupted oil shipments.

THE FIFTY-YEAR WOUND WE INFLICTED ON OURSELVES

Here lies the deepest irony of our predicament. India's catastrophic vulnerability to this foreign war is not merely a consequence of global markets. It is the direct result of a fifty-year act of governance failure — one that I have previously brought to the attention of your office by way of a detailed written submission.

I am, therefore, not raising this matter for the first time. I raise it again today because the crisis unfolding in the Persian Gulf has transformed what was, when I last wrote, an urgent domestic policy failure — into an active, immediate threat to India's national security. The CAG of India has since given institutional confirmation to precisely what I had submitted to you.

In 1974, in the wake of the Arab oil embargo and a global oil shock, the Parliament of India enacted the Oil Industry (Development) Act with a clear and visionary purpose: to levy a dedicated cess on domestic crude oil production, and to channel every rupee of it towards the Oil Industry Development Board (OIDB), to fund exploration, enhanced recovery, and energy self-sufficiency.

As the Supreme Court has consistently held, a "cess" is constitutionally and fundamentally distinct from a general tax. A tax flows into the Consolidated Fund for general purposes. A cess is an earmarked levy — money collected for a stated purpose, legally obligated to be spent on that purpose and no other. To collect a cess from an industry and then deny the proceeds to that very industry is a colourable exercise of power. In plain language, it is a fraud upon Parliament's own mandate.

Yet this is precisely what successive governments have done for five decades. According to the CAG, between FY 1974–75 and FY 2023–24, the Central Government collected a staggering ₹2,94,850.56 crore — nearly ₹2.95 lakh crore — from domestic oil producers under the OID cess. Of this legally mandated corpus, only ₹902.40 crore has ever been transferred to the OIDB. Not a single rupee has been transferred since FY 1991–92 (Audit Report No.16 of 2025).

99.7% of the cess collected over fifty years — money that was legally the property of India's energy security — was silently absorbed into general revenues to bridge fiscal deficits.

This was the precise capital required for deep-water exploration in the Krishna-Godavari basin, for Enhanced Oil Recovery in the aging fields of Assam and Gujarat, and for unlocking India's untapped shale reserves. By starving its domestic oil industry of this capital for fifty years, the Government of India actively engineered the import dependency that now makes us hostage to every missile fired in the Persian Gulf.

FROM DUBAI'S BOARDROOMS TO BOMB SHELTERS — AND WHY THIS IS INDIA'S CRISIS TOO

Hon'ble Prime Minister, let us now speak of what this war is doing in real time to the neighbourhood that houses nine million of our citizens and sustains the livelihoods of tens of millions more back home.

Explosions rocked Dubai's Palm Jumeirah man-made island and drone debris caused a fire at the Burj Al Arab ultra-luxury hotel as waves of Iranian missiles targeted the UAE. Dubai airport, the world's busiest for international traffic, and Jebel Ali seaport also suffered damage as the unprecedented attacks hit some of the city's major landmarks and revenue-earners.

Social media has already coined the bitter epitaph of this moment: "I came to Dubai for a tax shelter, but now I am hiding in a bomb shelter." The sentence captures, with devastating precision, what is being destroyed — not just buildings, but a promise of stability and prosperity that the Gulf has been making to the world, and to India, for decades.

This matters enormously to India.

The GCC nations have, over the past decade, been executing one of the most ambitious economic transformations in modern history. India was the natural beneficiary of all of this. In FY 2024-25, India-GCC bilateral trade reached $178.56 billion, accounting for 15.42% of India's global trade. The GCC region is also a significant source of FDI, with over $28.28 billion in GCC investment in India by December 2024. A prosperous, stable, diversifying Gulf was — and must continue to be — one of the most valuable strategic assets India possesses.

But the prosperity of the Gulf is built on a foundation that has a name: peace. When Iranian drones hit the Burj Al Arab and flames rise above Fairmont The Palm, the symbols of that prosperity, the calculation that built modern Dubai, is being repriced in real time.

The RBI report indicates that nearly 50% of India's overseas workforce is based in GCC nations, forming the backbone of the country's remittance ecosystem. Indian nationals in Gulf states send around 30% of the country's inward remittances. The UAE alone contributed $21.6 billion to India's record-breaking $129.4 billion remittance inflow in 2024. Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman, and Qatar together accounted for 11% of India's remittances, underscoring the Gulf's enduring relevance.

These are not statistics. These are the monthly transfers that pay school fees in Kerala, build homes in Andhra Pradesh, and sustain elderly parents in Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh. A disruption to the Gulf's prosperity — through war, through investor flight, through damage to the construction and hospitality sectors that employ the majority of blue-collar Indian workers — is a disruption to the daily lives of millions of Indian citizens living there.

The GCC countries count on India. They look to New Delhi as a trusted partner, a balanced voice, and a stable anchor in an increasingly fractured world. They count on us to speak when speaking matters. They count on us to be present when our presence has weight.

These are nations in distress. They are India's partners. And India has not yet spoken.

THE THREAT TO OUR ALREADY TROUBLED NEIGHBOURHOOD

Hon'ble Prime Minister, before we turn to the economics of India's direct vulnerability, there is another dimension of this crisis that demands acknowledgment: its consequences for the neighbourhood on our own borders.

A significant spike in global oil prices — of the kind that a war in the Persian Gulf guarantees — will not merely strain Pakistan's economy. It will accelerate a domestic crisis that has, historically, translated into the export of instability across our borders.

Bangladesh presents a parallel and equally worrisome picture. Bangladesh's own economy is under severe stress. A sharp oil price escalation will compound every one of its survival pressures.

An economically shattered Pakistan and a politically destabilized Bangladesh do not merely create humanitarian problems. They create security problems — directly and immediately — for India. Every ten dollars that a Gulf war adds to global oil prices makes our troubled neighbours more unstable. Every increment of instability in Islamabad or Dhaka translates, by the established logic of recent history, into heightened pressure on India's borders. India cannot address its border security in isolation from the economic health of the states on those borders. And the economic health of those states is directly threatened by every missile fired in the Strait of Hormuz.

This is yet one more reason why India cannot afford silence.

URGENT PRAYERS

In light of the foregoing, I respectfully and urgently pray that your government undertake the following immediate actions:

1. Assert India's Voice — Today, Not Tomorrow.

India must publicly and unequivocally condemn "Operation Epic Fury" as a violation of Article 2(4) of the UN Charter. We must call for an immediate ceasefire, demand the return of all parties to the negotiating table, and offer India's good offices as a trusted, neutral mediator. We must move urgently in the UN Security Council and the General Assembly to demand an emergency session on the protection of civilians in this war. The GCC nations, whose prosperity and stability are inextricably linked to India's own, are looking to New Delhi. We must not disappoint them in their moment of crisis.

2. Honour Parliament's Own Mandate — in the Forthcoming Parliamentary Session.

The Ministry of Finance must legally commit to transferring 100% of whatever OID cess is henceforth collected exclusively to the Oil Industry Development Board, for the purposes Parliament intended in 1974. The constitutional mockery identified by the CAG — 99.7% diverted over fifty years — must be formally ended. The fiscal regime governing domestic oil production must be restructured to incentivise domestic exploration.

Hon'ble Prime Minister, two crises have converged this week into one singular, historic moment of decision.

The first is the unlawful, strategically reckless destruction being visited upon the Iranian people — people already massacred by their own government, now bombed by foreign powers that promised them liberation and delivered carnage. Bombed while their schoolgirls were in their classrooms. Bombed while their government was, that very week, in diplomatic negotiations aimed at preventing war.

The second is fifty years of self-inflicted domestic failure — a ₹2.95 lakh crore betrayal of Parliament's own law — that has left India spending nearly ₹11.44 lakh crore every year on imported energy from the very nations now consumed by war; an annual drain nearly equal to the combined revenues of Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, and Karnataka; a drain that grows by the equivalent of an entire Kerala budget with every $10 rise in a barrel's price.

And between these two crises lies a third, quieter consequence: an increasingly unstable Pakistan and a politically restless Bangladesh — neighbours whose economic fragility is directly tied to global oil prices — becoming more dangerous along our own borders as the Gulf burns.

India cannot afford silence. A prosperous, peaceful Gulf is not merely in the interest of the nine million Indians who live there. It is in the strategic interest of the Republic of India itself. The GCC nations have been our partners, our employers of millions, and our investors. They have been building a post-oil future — in finance, technology, and tourism — that India was uniquely placed to participate in and benefit from. Every missile that falls on Dubai's skyline sets that future back. Every day of India's silence makes our voice, when we finally find it, worth less.

The schoolgirls of Minab did not die so that the world could look away. India must not be the nation that does.

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India