To
Hon’ble Prime Minister of India
Sri Narendra Modi
Government of India
New Delhi
Copy to:
Hon’ble Minister of Civil Aviation, Government of India
Secretary, Ministry of Civil Aviation
Director General of Civil Aviation (DGCA)
Chairperson, Airports Economic Regulatory Authority (AERA)
Chairperson, Competition Commission of India (CCI)
Subject: IndiGo flight chaos as a predictable outcome of extreme market concentration and dominance—urgent need for structural intervention in India’s aviation sector.
Hon’ble Prime Minister
I write this letter in my capacity as an advocate and as a citizen concerned about the unprecedented scale of disruption witnessed across India’s aviation network over the last few days. Thousands of passengers across multiple cities—Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Chennai and others—have been stranded by cascading cancellations by IndiGo, India’s largest airline. The magnitude and nationwide spread of the disruption demonstrate that this is not a routine operational lapse, but a systemic failure rooted in a deeper structural problem: the concentration of India’s domestic aviation market in the hands of a single airline.
Reports show that IndiGo cancelled hundreds of flights across multiple days, resulting in eight- to twelve-hour delays, stranded families with infants and senior citizens, and widespread confusion at airports. The airline itself has admitted planning failures in implementing the revised FDTL regulations for pilots. However, a planning error does not ordinarily paralyse a country’s aviation system—unless the airline committing that error carries a dominant share of all passengers flying within India.
Today, IndiGo controls over 64% of India’s domestic aviation market, according to global aviation analyses and independent media profiles. By comparison, in the United States civil aviation market—the top four airlines together control 69% of domestic passenger volume. Put differently, IndiGo alone is almost equal to the entire U.S. oligopoly combined. No major democracy in the world has permitted such market power to concentrate in a single private airline without corresponding public-interest obligations.
India has witnessed an extraordinary aviation boom. Between 2012–13 and 2019–20, India’s domestic passenger traffic rose from 98 million to 202 million (9.8 crore to 20.2 crore). In 2024, DGCA data shows 161 million domestic passengers (16.1 crore). International estimates place India’s total passenger volume (domestic + international) at over 24 crore passengers annually, making India the world’s fifth-largest aviation market. For this combined metric, projections show that by 2030, India will cross 50 crore passengers a year. Yet, this explosive growth is unfolding within a dangerously imbalanced market structure.
India’s domestic aviation today is, in practical terms, a duopoly sliding into a growing monopoly. IndiGo carries roughly 10 crore domestic passengers a year. The Air India group, still stabilising after privatisation, holds about 27%. All other carriers together account for barely 7–8%. This is not a competitive market—it is a structural dependency on a single private operator. When an airline so large fails to plan for a regulatory change, we witness what we just saw.
The Economist, in a major profile on IndiGo (August 2024), notes that the airline is among the world’s ten biggest airlines by number of flights, has placed the largest aircraft order in world aviation history (500 planes), and inducts one new aircraft every week. Another Economist analysis (November 2023) observes that India is building airports at unprecedented speed—149 operational civil airports today, up from 74 a decade ago, with plans for nearly 15 dual-airport cities by 2040. Thus, India is turning into an aviation-supported economy - without aviation competition.
The recent cancellations must therefore be seen as a warning bell. The Indian economy—worth USD 4 trillion and growing—cannot afford a scenario where a single airline is so large that its internal missteps become a form of national infrastructure failure.
International evidence from Canada, the United States, Australia and New Zealand demonstrates a clear and consistent pattern:
- When one or two airlines dominate, fares rise sharply.
- Monopoly routes in Australia charge nearly 40 cents per kilometre, while the entry of a second airline reduces fares to under 30 cents per kilometre.
- Each additional competitor reduces fares by 5–10%.
- In the U.S., when a market drops from three airlines to two, average delays increase by about 25%, and fares rise 10–12%.
- In New Zealand, dominated by a single airline (Air NZ with 85% share), domestic fares rose up to 55% after consolidation and remain about 32% higher than pre-pandemic levels.
This is not theory—these are empirically measured consequences of aviation concentration.
India is now on the same path. With IndiGo at over 64% market share, and Air India Group acquiring 470 aircraft (with options for 370 more), India is poised to become a two-player system controlling nearly all trunk routes. In such markets:
- Fares rise even during periods of stable fuel prices.
- Cancellation and delay compensation goes unenforced, because consumers have no alternatives.
- Regional connectivity suffers.
- Operational failures by one airline cause national chaos.
This structural concentration has already produced damaging consequences: a sustained and sharp rise in airfares. Independent reporting by Al Jazeera (2 December 2025) shows that domestic airfares have risen by up to 43% compared to pre-pandemic levels. News Karnataka further documents that fares on many domestic routes have risen 40–50% since 2019, with one-way fares that earlier cost ₹3,300 now routinely exceeding ₹5,000. ATF cost increases explain part of this, but experts cited in these reports unequivocally attribute a significant share of fare escalation to shrinking competition. With fewer airlines and near-total dominance by two groups, the market no longer disciplines pricing.
A distressing trend has emerged: despite expanding airports, new terminals, and the Union Government’s own push through the UDAN scheme to democratise air travel, aviation is silently becoming inaccessible again. As both Al Jazeera and News Karnataka report, the lower and lower-middle classes—the intended beneficiaries of UDAN—are increasingly priced out. Air travel is no longer a vehicle of mobility for crores of Indians seeking opportunity across a vast nation.
The cries from the recent crisis have shown once again that air travel in India is now essential for professional, medical, educational and familial reasons. For crores of Indians, it is not a luxury—it is a basic economic necessity that enables Article 19(1)(g) freedoms and, in emergencies, Article 21 rights. When the domestic aviation network becomes unpredictable or expensive due to the dominance of a single carrier, constitutional values cannot be unharmed or unhurt.
Policy Interventions Needed: In light of these facts, I respectfully urge the Union Government to consider the following measures:
(1) A Strengthened Passenger Rights Charter with Automatic Enforcement-
- Mandatory, automatic compensation for delays and cancellations.
- Obligation on dominant airlines to rebook passengers on competing carriers at the airline’s cost, where seats exist.
- Strict penalties for misinformation, non-disclosure and withholding of cancellation notifications.
- Monthly DGCA publication of compliance rankings.
(2) A Suo Motu Competition Commission Inquiry into Market Structure-
The CCI must urgently examine:
- Whether IndiGo’s market share creates a barrier to entry.
- Whether slot allocation at major airports is foreclosing competition.
- Whether the planned fleet expansions of IndiGo and Air India will result in future market foreclosure.
- Whether structural remedies are needed, such as market-share caps, slot divestitures or behavioural conditions.
(3) A Joint Aviation–Competition–Consumer Task Force-
Bringing together the Ministry of Civil Aviation, DGCA, AERA, CCI and Department of Consumer Affairs to produce within six months a framework addressing:
- Entry of new domestic carriers.
- Fair slot access.
- Competition safeguards on trunk routes.
- Regional connectivity obligations.
- Strengthened consumer protections.
A Constitutional and Economic Warning: India is building airports, runways and terminals at historic speed. Fifty crore passengers a year will fly within this country by 2030 (combined). Yet, unless the Government introduces structural remedies now, this massive national aviation architecture will rest on a fragile pillar dominated by a single or two airlines. That is a systemic risk India cannot afford.
This letter is written in the public interest, and I intend to place it in the public domain to contribute responsibly to national debate.