To
The Hon’ble Chief Minister
Government of Karnataka
Sri Siddaramaiah
Copy to:
The Hon’ble Law Minister
Government of Karnataka
Sri H.K Patil
To
The Hon’ble Leader of Opposition
Karnataka Legislative Assembly
Sri R Ashoka
Subject: Urgent Appeal to Legislatively Repeal within the territory of the State of Karnataka:
- the Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita, 2023 (BNS) and Retain the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC);
- the Bharatiya Nagarika Surakshata Sanhita, 2023 and Retain the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973; and
- the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 and Retain the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
Respected Sirs
I am writing to you with great concern regarding the impending implementation of the Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita, 2023 (BNS) and its companion legislations, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. These legislations are set to replace the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, respectively, on July 1, 2024. The Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita, 2023 (BNS) and its companion legislations, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 were passed by the Parliament of India in 2023.
As an advocate practicing in various jurisdictions, including the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, I feel compelled to bring to your attention the grave risks and drastic consequences associated with this drastic and unsafe rewriting of our laws that define the criminal justice system.
The Hasty Implementation of the BNS:
The decision to implement these new laws, particularly the BNS, on July 1, 2024, was made by the outgoing government of Prime Minister Sri Narendra Modi on February 23, 2024. This move is highly irregular and sets a dangerous precedent for India. It is uncommon and unwaranted for an outgoing government to set a future date for the enactment of a law when it is uncertain if it will still be in power.
The BNS: A Repackaged Version of the IPC
Despite being hailed as a path breaking piece of legislation, the BNS is, in reality, little more than a repackaged version of the Indian Penal Code. An estimated 75-80% of its language is lifted directly from its colonial-era predecessor. This raises serious questions about the very wisdom of discarding a legal code that has stood the test of time for over 160 years.
The Global Impact of the IPC
The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) has had a profound impact on legal systems across the globe. It represents the first successful attempt to codify criminal law throughout the British Empire. Its reach extends far beyond India's borders, with direct application in numerous jurisdictions across Africa and Asia, including Nigeria, Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei. Its indirect impact can be traced to the criminal codes of Canada and Australia, and even the United States Model Penal Code bears its imprint.
The Enduring Relevance of the IPC
The benefit of the IPC lies in its clarity and precision, a quality that sets it apart from comparable legislation of both the 19th and 21st centuries. Despite the numerous changes and challenges that India has faced over the past 160 years, the IPC has remained relatively unchanged, with fewer amendments since 1950 compared even to the Constitution of independent India. The fact that India's Parliament, in the year 2023, saw fit to copy substantial portions of a law drafted in 1860 in a law meant to replace it is a testament to the enduring relevance and efficacy of the IPC.
The Singapore Example
It is worth noting that Singapore, a nation consistently ranked among those with the lowest crime rates globally, has relied on a 1871 Penal Code that was originally a replica of the IPC. Singapore has made fewer amendments to its Penal Code over the years, suggesting that the IPC's framework remains very effective in the modern era.
Potential Consequences of Hasty Implementation
The hasty implementation of the BNS and its companion legislations threatens to unleash a cascade of unintended consequences that could cripple India's already overburdened criminal justice system. Our nation's courts are burdened with cases that routinely take years, if not decades, to conclude.
The introduction of these new laws is likely to exacerbate existing difficulties, as law enforcement agencies and the judiciary grapple with the challenges of adapting to a new legal framework. Police officers, already struggling to keep pace with the demands of the current system, will inevitably require additional time and resources to familiarize themselves with the intricacies of apparently new but repackaged criminal codes. This period of adjustment could create a window of opportunity for offenders to exploit, leading to a surge in criminal activities – all in the name of legislative experiments with no known virtues or objectives.
The Need for a Pilot Implementation
It would be reasonable to be skeptical of the proposed implementation of the BNS and its companion legislations. It would have been wise for the Parliament to consider piloting these new laws in a smaller jurisdiction allowing for a controlled evaluation of their impact and effectiveness before rolling them out nationwide.
Linguistic and Cultural Concerns
The decision to title the new laws in Hindi, despite criminal law being a subject on which both the Parliament and the State legislatures have legislative authority, risks alienating India's diverse states and union territories. This move could be interpreted as an attempt to impose a narrow, nationalistic vision of India's legal system, disregarding the nation's rich linguistic diversity. It is not difficult to imagine a scenario in which individual States, particularly in the south and the east, feeling slighted by the Central Government's actions, choose to enact their own legislation to repeal these new laws within their borders and revert to the existing laws.
The Need for Urgent Action
Given the potential risks and consequences associated with the implementation of the BNS and its companion legislations, I urge you, as key leaders in our State, to take immediate action.
I respectfully request that you consider the urgent need to:
a) immediately pass legislations in the Karnataka Legislature to oppose the implementation of the new laws by repealing them within the territory of Karnataka. A repeal would restore the laws that prevailed until 1st July, 2024 – the Indian Penal Code, 1860, Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872;
b) engage with other State Governments to form a coalition to oppose these destabilizing legal changes;
c) advocate for a more measured and deliberative approach to legal reform at the national level, including the piloting of these laws in a smaller jurisdiction before nationwide implementation.
The stakes could not be higher. The hasty implementation of the BNS and its companion legislations threatens to unleash chaos and confusion in our criminal justice system. It is our collective responsibility to advocate for a measured, responsible approach to legal reform that prioritizes the stability and effectiveness of our nation's criminal justice system.
Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I look forward to your prompt action in safeguarding the integrity of our legal system and to prevent it from a highly unsafe experiment.