A Demand That the Bengaluru Police Immediately Stop the Random Drug Testing of Students in Educational Institutions. Students Who Tested Positive Should Not Get Into Legal Trouble.

The Bengaluru Police's Sanmitra initiative deserves one honest acknowledgment before it receives the reckoning it must. Drug abuse among young students is real. The police genuinely wish to help. That much is to their credit.

The police, however, are a creation of the law. The same law that brought them into existence knew — from long and hard experience — where they could go wrong. So it placed clear limitations on their power. Those limitations are not obstacles placed against the police. They are protections placed for the public. Observing them is not a courtesy. It is a duty.

The road to hell, as the saying goes, is paved with good intentions.

I call upon the Bengaluru Police and the Karnataka State Police to immediately stop this mass drug testing drive, and to not expand it to other educational institutions, other divisions, or other cities in Karnataka.

The Law Is Not a Bureaucratic Obstacle.

Urine samples were collected from over 1,200 college students in Vijayanagar, of which 585 were tested and 31 found positive. The police claim the exercise was conducted with the consent of institutional managements. A college principal manages an institution. A college principal does not own the bodies of students, however.

Such random drug testing by police is not recognised or permissible under the law. Under the NDPS Act, Gazetted Officers can authorise searches based on information taken down in writing. Searches can also be made without a warrant under certain circumstances. Neither provision remotely contemplates mass collection of bodily samples from unarrested civilians attending college. Under the BNSS, medical examination is permitted only in certain circumstances that do not apply here.

These safeguards were not drafted to frustrate police officers. Every one of them is distilled historical experience — the experience of a democracy that learned, at great cost, what happens when authority is exercised without legal warrant. The law is the only reliable guarantee against the abuse of authority by the next officer who may not be as well-intentioned as this one.

The Same Compassion, Far Better Alternatives

The police's own officers admit the real target is drug peddlers, not users. The NDPS Act gives full authority to pursue peddlers with intelligence-led investigations and targeted searches. Use that law — it works, and it is constitutional.

If the goal is information about peddlers, announce a substantial monetary reward scheme for credible tip-offs. A well-funded reward programme with guaranteed anonymity will yield more actionable intelligence in a month than a thousand urine cups tested in a week. Students who know who supplies drugs on campus will come forward when they are protected and rewarded. They will not come forward when they feel surveilled and violated. Intelligence built on trust outlasts intelligence extracted through coercion.

Now, should the police respond by saying that a tip-off — even a credible one — is not as useful as an actual consumer whose consumption has been clinically tested and proven, one must pause and worry. Because that argument, if made, reveals one of two things: either the police have not thought this through carefully at all, or they have thought it through and the implications are worse.

If a proven consumer is more valuable to the police than an informant, it means the police intend — at some point — to use that student as a witness. A witness whose drug use is on record. A witness who was never formally arrested, never formally cautioned, never afforded the protections the law requires before a body is examined and a result recorded.

If, on the other hand, the police genuinely never intend to use the student as a witness — if the test result is truly only for information and counselling purposes — then a monetary reward scheme and anonymous counselling would have served the stated purpose entirely. Either way, the mass urine testing of 1,200 students had no defensible justification. It was either unnecessary, or it was the first step in a process whose consequences the police have not fully considered.

Addiction Education

What actually protects young people is education. Addiction must be explained in classrooms — honestly and without the moral theatre that surrounds drug policy. Students must be taught what addiction is: a neurological phenomenon, not a character flaw. They must understand how the brain's reward pathways are hijacked by substance dependence — whether the substance is cannabis, heroin, alcohol, nicotine, or prescription opioids. They must be taught about the decisions they make, why they might be making it, how to not make those decisions and what it means to own the consequences of one's decisions.

They must also be taught precisely what the law says — which substances are banned under the NDPS Act and what the punishments are. Rigorous imprisonment ranging from one year to twenty years, and substantial fines. A student who understands both the pharmacological reality and the legal consequences is far better equipped to make an informed.

A Special Word About Law Colleges

If a law college was part of this drive, and its students presented their bodies for random sampling by uniformed police officers without demanding to see the legal authority for the exercise — without citing the NDPS Act, BNSS, Constitution of India or the Puttaswamy judgment — then that law college's affiliation ought to be reviewed by the Bar Council of India. A law college that produces students incapable of identifying a constitutional violation when it is being committed upon their own bodies, in their own classrooms, is not a law college. It is a certificate shop. And those students, having demonstrated that their legal education produced no instinct for either rights or resistance, would be well-advised to reflect carefully on whether the legal profession is where they truly belong.

The Right Against Self-Incrimination

Article 20(3) of the Constitution guarantees that no person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. This is not a technicality — it is a moral cornerstone. The nations with the lowest crime rates — Norway, Finland, Denmark — are precisely those where due process rights are most scrupulously observed. Compelling children to produce bodily samples that may incriminate them violates this protection and plants fear — not wisdom — in young minds. Fear does not build character. It builds resentment. In Karnataka, where videos of police misconduct— in police stations, on roads, in custody — surface regularly and the police must do far more to earn greater public trust, what just happened is coercion with a friendly name. This must end.

Immediately stop this drive. Counsel the students. Educate the students. Reward those who inform on peddlers. Pursue peddlers with the full force of the law. But do not test the bodies of free citizens without lawful authority.

Signed PDF of this piece

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India