The Karnataka Government has withdrawn its order of 5 February 2022 on school and college uniforms. That earlier order had kept several students wearing the hijab out of their classrooms and had led to litigation in the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court. The new order reportedly allows limited articles of faith — hijab, turban, janivara, rudraksha and the like — so long as discipline, safety, identification and the school uniform are respected.
This withdrawal is lawful. It is not contempt of court. And it should not be confused with the larger constitutional question, which still remains open.
The Government can withdraw its own order
The 2022 order was issued under the Karnataka Education Act, 1983. Under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 — a principle also reflected in the Karnataka General Clauses Act, 1899 — the power to make an order includes the power to change it or take it back. No court had directed the Karnataka Government to keep that order in force. The Karnataka High Court had upheld it in Resham v. State of Karnataka (15 March 2022); the High Court had not ordered that it must continue. A Government is always free to reconsider its own policy. It is not contempt.
The Supreme Court has not yet decided the merits
In further appeal — Aishat Shifa v. State of Karnataka, decided on 13 October 2022 — the Supreme Court delivered a split verdict. Hon'ble Justice Hemant Gupta dismissed the appeals and upheld the Karnataka High Court judgement. Hon'ble Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia allowed the appeal and set aside the High Court judgment. The matter was therefore placed before the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger Bench.
As of today, the larger Bench has not been constituted and there is no binding decision of the Supreme Court on whether wearing the hijab in a classroom is constitutionally protected. That question is still open. The withdrawal of the State's order does not answer it.
The constitutional question has not gone away
A Government changing its order does not end a constitutional question of national importance. The Supreme Court has, in earlier cases, decided important questions even after the immediate facts had changed.
In S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, (1994) 3 SCC 1, a nine-judge Bench decided fundamental questions about President's Rule and secularism, even though the dismissed State Governments could no longer be restored because of intervening elections. The Court did so because the issues were of constitutional significance.
The hijab question is of similar constitutional importance. And it is not limited to Karnataka:
- In 2024, the Bombay High Court heard a challenge to a Mumbai college's dress code that restricted hijab, niqab and similar clothing. On appeal, the Supreme Court partly stayed that restriction.
- Similar disputes around the hijab and the school uniform have also reached the Kerala High Court, raising concerns of dignity, privacy and access to education.
The real question is this: How does the Constitution balance school discipline with a child's religious expression? That question will return, in different States and different schools, until the Supreme Court answers it.
On the saffron-shawl controversy
If any parent can genuinely show that a saffron shawl is part of a long-standing religious or cultural practice in the family, and that the child would otherwise be kept away from school, the Government must consider it on the same terms as any other article of faith.
But if a kesari shawl is being brought into the classroom only as a political reply to another community's practice, that is a different matter. The Constitution does not require the State to treat sincere faith and political protest as the same thing.