The present constitutional situation in Tamil Nadu is a matter of substantial public interest. I am therefore issuing this statement on the impasse that has arisen after the election to the Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly.

The election has produced a hung Assembly. The Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly has 234 seats. The majority mark in a full House is 118.

As per the party-wise result declared by the Election Commission of India,

PartySeats Won
Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK)108
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK)59
All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK)47
Indian National Congress (INC)5
Pattali Makkal Katchi (PMK)4
Indian Union Muslim League (IUML)2
Communist Party of India (CPI)2
Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK)2
Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPI-M)2
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)1
Desiya Murpokku Dravida Kazhagam (DMDK)1
Amma Makkal Munnettra Kazagam (AMMK)1
Total234

The pre-poll coalition position is equally important. TVK contested on its own and emerged as the single largest party. The DMK-led Secular Progressive Alliance comprised the DMK, Congress, DMDK, VCK, CPI, CPI(M), IUML, MDMK and other smaller regional parties. The winning parties from that pre-poll formation together accounted for 73 seats, although the Congress has since reportedly extended support to TVK. The AIADMK-led/NDA formation comprised the AIADMK, BJP, PMK, AMMK, Tamil Maanila Congress, Indhiya Jananayaga Katchi, Puratchi Bharatham, Tamilaga Makkal Munnetra Kazhagam and other smaller allies. The winning parties from that formation together account for 53 seats. Therefore, neither any single party nor any pre-poll coalition has secured a majority.

In independent India, there has hardly been a comparable situation where a person has founded a political party barely two years before an election and, in a large, politically mature and industrially important State such as Tamil Nadu, displaced entrenched political formations to emerge as the single largest party in the Legislative Assembly. Tamil Nadu is one of India’s most industrialised and export-oriented States and sends one of the largest contingents of Members of Parliament to the Lok Sabha. Its verdicts are therefore of national significance.

The performance of TVK and Mr. C. Joseph Vijay upsets several assumptions about how electoral politics works in India. It also shows that the electorate is capable of moving beyond conventional party structures, inherited political loyalties and familiar social arithmetic.

The question before the Governor is not whether Mr. Vijay has achieved a historic political result. He undoubtedly has. The question before the Governor is whether Mr. Vijay has demonstrated that he commands, or is in a position to command, the confidence of the House.

On the present numbers, TVK has 108 seats. The Congress Party, which has 5 seats, has reportedly extended support to Mr. Vijay. Even if the Congress support is added, the figure reaches only 113. That is still short of the majority mark of 118 in a full House. Further, since Mr. Vijay has won from two constituencies, he will necessarily have to relinquish one seat. Once that happens, TVK’s effective strength would come down to 107, and with Congress support, the figure would be 112. Even if the working majority is then computed on the basis of a 233- member House, the required number would be 117. Either way, TVK and Congress together do not presently cross the majority mark.

In my opinion, the Governor is constitutionally justified in asking Mr. Vijay to produce letters of support sufficient to establish a majority. A person who claims the right to form the Government must show that he has the support of enough elected members. The Governor cannot be expected to act on hope, speculation, private assurances or political optimism.

A floor test is undoubtedly the proper constitutional method to test majority - when a person has already shown a credible basis for claiming majority support. But a floor test cannot be converted into a device to permit a party to first take oath and then search for a majority. The Constitution does not require the Governor to facilitate a post-oath search for numbers.

The present situation must also be viewed in the context of pre-poll alliances. Most of the parties which have won seats in Tamil Nadu contested as part of one or the other pre-poll formation. If Mr. Vijay seeks to form the Government by obtaining support from parties or MLAs who fought the election as part of another pre-poll alliance, that support must be open, voluntary and placed on record before the Governor.

In the present case, there is also no meaningful “free float” of MLAs which could permit the Governor to act differently. This is not a case where a sizeable number of independents or unattached smaller parties are available outside the principal pre-poll formations, leaving the Governor to assess which claimant is more likely to attract their support. The House is composed almost entirely of parties which either contested as part of identifiable pre-poll coalitions or, in the case of TVK, contested on its own. Therefore, any additional support to Mr. Vijay, beyond the Congress Party’s reported five seats, would necessarily have to come from parties or MLAs who were elected as part of another pre-poll political arrangement. In such a situation, the Governor cannot presume possible defections, post-poll realignments or silent support. He must insist upon clear, written and verifiable letters of support. The absence of a genuine free float makes the Governor’s caution even more necessary, because inviting a claimant without demonstrated majority support would not be an act of constitutional neutrality; it may create the very conditions for alliance-breaking and horse-trading.

It would not be healthy for democracy if Raj Bhavan were to knowingly create conditions in which pre-poll alliances are broken through inducement, pressure or opportunistic post-poll arrangements. The evil of horse-trading is real. Where there is no substantial body of independents or unattached MLAs, and where the missing numbers must necessarily be obtained from within rival pre-poll formations, the Governor must be especially careful not to become an instrument through which an artificial majority is manufactured.

If any party or MLA wishes to support Mr. Vijay, there is nothing preventing them from giving a clear letter of support. If such letters are produced and the number crosses the majority mark, the Governor would then be duty-bound to invite Mr. Vijay to form the Government and require him to prove his majority on the floor of the House within a short and reasonable time.

However, if parties or MLAs are unwilling to give written support but merely convey that they may support Mr. Vijay on the floor of the House, such secret or uncertain assurances cannot become the constitutional basis for Government formation. Democracy requires transparency. A Government cannot be born out of whispers.

Tamil Nadu has had difficult experiences with the office of the Governor. In the past, serious constitutional questions arose when assent to Bills passed by the Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly was delayed for long periods, and the Supreme Court had occasion to examine such conduct. The people of Tamil Nadu are therefore justified in being vigilant about the conduct of Raj Bhavan. It is also fair to clarify that the present Governor, Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar, is not the Governor whose conduct in delaying assent to Bills passed by the Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly came under the scrutiny of the Supreme Court. That controversy concerned his predecessor.

In the present case, the Governor is only asking for demonstrable majority support. On the figures presently available, that insistence is lawful, reasonable and constitutionally prudent. Had the Governor of Tamil Nadu invited Mr. Vijay, as leader of the largest single party with declared Congress support, and required him to face the floor within a short and defined window, that course would have been amply backed by precedent. But not following precedent is not the same as acting unconstitutionally. Precedent is a guide; it does not exhaust the Governor's discretion. In the present case, every elected MLA save the 108 of TVK and the 5 of Congress sits within a rival pre-poll alliance, and the gap to 118 cannot be bridged except by drawing from those formations. Where there is no genuine free float, where pre-poll alliances would have to be cracked open to manufacture a majority, and where the claimant has himself produced letters totalling only 112, the Governor's insistence on demonstrable majority support before extending an invitation is a permissible exercise of constitutional caution — different from the Goa (2017) and Karnataka (2018) instances.

Tamil Nadu deserves a stable Government. It also deserves a constitutionally clean process of Government formation. Mr. Vijay’s mandate is historic. TVK’s emergence is extraordinary. In my view, the correct constitutional position is simple. If Mr. Vijay produces clear letters of support crossing the majority mark, the Governor must invite him to form the Government. Until then, the Governor is justified in insisting on letters of support. The Governor must neither obstruct a legitimate majority nor facilitate an artificial one.

Signed PDF of this piece

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India