On 30 July, through a Press Note, I had asked that the papers filed by Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Puducherry before the Cauvery Water Management Authority and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee be placed in the public domain. Seven weeks have passed. They are still not public.

My request was never merely for the final number of cusecs. It was for the record from which that number comes: the storage and inflow figures each State places before the Authority, the demands and objections of the parties, their claims of drinking-water and irrigation need, and their periodic returns of inflow, storage, release and consumption. That was the request on 30 July. It is the request today.

Much has happened in between.

The Authority has issued three further fortnightly directions to Karnataka: 12,000 cusecs a day from 12 August, 9,000 cusecs a day after its meeting of 25 August, and 6,000 cusecs a day for fifteen days from 9 September.

The Supreme Court heard the dispute on 17, 24 and 31 August. On 17 August, it told Karnataka to comply with the Authority's directions. On 24 August, it sent Tamil Nadu's grievance about its proportionate share back to the Authority. On 31 August, it noted that the Committee sits every fifteen days and hears the parties before it orders.

Karnataka has since challenged the 6,000-cusec direction before the Supreme Court. On 16 September, it also asked the Authority to cut the flow to 3,000 cusecs a day. In that plea, Karnataka is reported to have said that its four main reservoirs held 55.389 tmcft of live storage on 15 September, while projecting requirements of 144 tmcft for irrigation and drinking water, including Bengaluru, and a further 10 tmcft for environmental flows.

So the dispute is now being managed fortnight by fortnight, before the statutory bodies established to regulate the river. The public sees the number that comes out. The complete record that went in is not publicly available.

Tamil Nadu has told the Supreme Court that substantial quantities due to it have not arrived, and that nearly 24,700 acres of its farmland depend on Cauvery water. Karnataka says the basin is in severe distress and that its reservoirs must first meet drinking-water and irrigation needs within the State. Each version rests on figures filed before the Authority. The public should be able to test both against the same material the Authority has.

The stakes are not abstract. Drinking water in Karnataka and irrigation on both sides of the border are being balanced in these decisions. Farmers and citizens hear radically different accounts of the same river from different parties. The underlying record would let those different accounts be examined.

There is a longer-term reason too. What is decided this year may shape how the next distress year is handled. How shortage is measured, how drinking water is ranked against crops, how one State's need is weighed against another's, how the burden of scarcity is shared — these questions are being answered now, meeting after meeting. That process should leave a record the public can read.

I know of no other public call for this record. The people who drink from this river and farm along it deserve to see it. That is why I am asking again.

My request is simple. After every meeting, the Authority and the Committee should publish the agenda, the minutes, the written submissions and returns filed by Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Puducherry, the Biligundlu flow data relied on for the period, and the reasons for the direction issued.

In 2018, the Supreme Court held that the waters of an inter-State river are a national asset and that no single State can claim exclusive ownership of them. The record on which a national asset is being allocated in a year of scarcity deserves to be seen by the people whose drinking water, crops and livelihoods depend on it.

Seven weeks ago, I asked that this record be made public.

I ask again today.

Signed PDF of this piece

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India