Re: Police Communication NR-464/GR-200: Protecting Lawful Protest and Confronting the Cancer of Corruption – Police Action against members of Karnataka Rashtra Samithi (KRS), a registered political party.

On this Republic Day, as we celebrate our Constitution, we must confront the challenges threatening our democracy. Corruption in India and Karnataka has reached dangerous proportions.

Most people discover cancer only at Stage 3 or 4, when it has metastasised and treatment options are limited. The same tragic pattern applies to corruption. By the time citizens finally perceive the extent of institutional rot, it has spread to vital organs of governance. The society that normalises corruption surrenders its future.

Those few Indians who do perceive the worsening corruption—and speak against it—are performing a diagnostic function. They are the early warning system. They deserve protection and support, not persecution.

It is from this standpoint that I address a recent development involving Karnataka Police and the Karnataka Rashtra Samiti (KRS), a registered political party that has been actively campaigning against corruption. Political parties engaging in peaceful protest against governmental corruption are exercising rights fundamental to democratic functioning.

The Police Communication

Consider the communication bearing reference NR-464/GR-200 from the Office of the Director General of Police, Karnataka. The document dated 22 January 2026 forwards a private representation alleging disruption of official duties to jurisdictional police officers for "action in accordance with law."

Importantly, the communication does not direct registration of criminal cases, does not mandate filing of complaints, and does not instruct initiation of prosecution or filing of FIRs. It is, on its face, an administrative act of transmission.

A Troubling Question.

However, a deeper question arises: Why forward such a representation at all?

When someone requests legally impermissible action—such as directing criminal prosecution against members of a political party engaged in protest—the appropriate response is to inform the individual that such action cannot be ordered, not to forward the request.

Forwarding without clear rejection places subordinate officers in a difficult position. In a hierarchical organisation, such ambiguity can trigger overzealous action driven by perceived expectations rather than legal requirements. A senior officer confronting a legally untenable request has a duty to refuse—not to pass it down the chain.

Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, FIR registration requires information disclosing a cognizable offence. No superior officer can direct registration absent these preconditions.

The Supreme Court in Ramlila Maidan Incident v. Home Secretary (2012) affirmed that citizens have a fundamental right to peaceful protest that cannot be taken away by arbitrary action.

I state that the Police communication is not a direction to prosecute KRS members. However, forwarding a legally untenable request—without rejecting it—raises legitimate concerns about institutional intent.

The cancer of corruption thrives on public apathy. When citizens finally awaken, they often find the disease has spread beyond easy remedy. Those who raise early alarms—whether individuals or political parties—must be heard, not silenced.

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India