I have no personal connection to Dr. C. J. Roy or his family. I hold no brief for or against any political party or Central agency. I did not know the man.
So why am I issuing this press release?
Because I have practiced law long enough to know what happens when powerful interests are at stake. An inquest into the death of Dr. C. J. Roy is a public proceeding—conducted not for the benefit of any private party, but to establish the truth about an unnatural death for the benefit of society at large. The public has a legitimate interest in its outcome.
If a person who visits or is arrested and taken to a police station is found dead on its premises, heads roll. Inquiries are ordered. Officers are suspended. The State is held accountable—swiftly and publicly—because a death in the presence of State officials is a matter of grave concern.
Dr. Roy shot himself while Income Tax officials were conducting proceedings at his premises in Bengaluru. He was, in effect, in the presence of the State. The same standard must apply. A man died on their watch. The public is entitled to know what happened—and the Income Tax Department is obligated to tell the public.
We Have Been Here Before
This is not the first time. In July 2019, V.G. Siddhartha—founder of Café Coffee Day, one of India's recognised brands then—was found dead in the Netravati river. He allegedly left behind a letter speaking of "harassment" by Income Tax officials. We never got the full truth. The inquiry produced no public reckoning. The questions faded. The news cycle moved on.
Now, less than seven years later, another entrepreneur is dead. Another set of Income Tax officials were present. Another set of competing narratives—tax harassment versus political pressure—has emerged. Another family is grieving.
The Income Tax Department's silence after Siddhartha's death set a precedent. Its silence now will confirm a pattern.
The Larger Context
India is haemorrhaging talent and capital. A record number of high-net-worth individuals have renounced India for jurisdictions that treat them with less suspicion. The reasons are many, but one recurs with troubling frequency: tax terrorism.
The phrase is not mine. It describes a regime of investigation, raid, summons, and seizure that often operates less as law enforcement and more as institutionalised intimidation. Assessees speak of being treated as guilty until proven innocent. Of searches conducted not to uncover evasion but to extract confession. Of reputations destroyed while cases wind through tribunals for decades.
Not every tax investigation is terrorism. The Government has a legitimate interest in ensuring compliance. But when the process itself becomes the punishment—when the mere initiation of proceedings is sufficient to break a person—something has gone deeply wrong.
Dr. Roy died on January 30, 2026, while Income Tax officials were present at his premises. This fact will be remembered by some entrepreneurs weighing whether to build a business in India, by investors calculating political risk, by young professionals deciding whether to stay or join the exodus out of India.
A Punishment Beyond Anything the Law Prescribes
The Income Tax Act prescribes penalties for evasion. In serious cases, it prescribes prosecution. The punishment—even for substantial evasion—is a fine, or imprisonment for a term of years, or both. It is not a life sentence. It is certainly not death.
And yet, Dr. Roy is dead. V.G. Siddhartha is dead.
What was done to them—or what did they fear would be done—that made death seem preferable to facing the process of law?
In the ordinary course of tax proceedings, people do not take their own lives. They engage lawyers. They file appeals. They negotiate. They endure. They fight back. They do not reach for a firearm.
If the IT officers conducted themselves with propriety, and if Dr. Roy's death was the result of pressures unconnected to their proceedings—as is reported in media attributing its sources to the IT Department—the IT Department should say so. Clearly, publicly, and on the record.
If the IT Department possesses information suggesting that Dr. Roy was caught in a web not of its making—that he was laundering money for politically powerful persons in Karnataka, that the true source of his terror lay elsewhere—then the IT Department must say that too. Openly, officially, and with accountability.
If the Department Knew, Why Did It Not Act?
Let us take the Department's reported narrative at face value for a moment.
If, as media reports attributed to the Income Tax Department suggest, Dr. Roy was laundering money for powerful Karnataka politicians—and if he was being hounded by them for returns on their investments—then the IT Department was in possession of information suggesting that a citizen under its scrutiny was subject to criminal intimidation and extortion by powerful persons.
In such circumstances, did the IT Department not have an obligation to act?
Did it not have a duty to alert the State Police—or, if it lacked confidence in the State Police given the alleged involvement of State-level politicians, the Central Bureau of Investigation?
Did it not have a duty to file a formal complaint, placing on record the threat it claims to have known about? Did it not have a duty to ensure the protection of a person who, on its own account, was caught between its investigation and the predations of politically powerful individuals?
If the IT Department knew that Dr. Roy was being squeezed from multiple directions—and did nothing despite a duty to act and report—then its failure to report demands explanation.
The Duty to the Public and to the SIT
The Karnataka Government has constituted a Special Investigation Team to inquire into the circumstances of Dr. Roy's death. The SIT is conducting an inquest—a public proceeding aimed at establishing the cause of an unnatural death. The purpose of an inquest is not to serve private interests; it is to serve the public interest in truth and accountability.
The Income Tax Department owes a duty to both the public and the SIT. To the public, it owes an explanation. To the SIT, it owes full disclosure of all relevant information.
And if this tragedy is to have any meaning beyond grief, the IT Department must establish clear protocols for the future: when an assessee under investigation is found to be subject to threats, intimidation, or pressure from third parties—particularly powerful political actors—the Department must have a duty to report, to refer, and ensure protection.
V.G. Siddhartha is dead. Dr. C. J. Roy is dead. Does it end with them? The dead cannot speak. Somebody living and not afraid must.
This press release is issued in public interest.