I am presently counsel in two defamation suits of ₹100 crore each — one for the plaintiff, one for a defendant — so I follow defamation filings with some professional interest. This week's filing in the Delhi High Court deserves a note.

Shri Gaurav Bhatia, BJP spokesperson and Senior Advocate, has sued certain individuals associated with the Cockroach Janta Party for ₹2 crore over an AI-generated graphic — deleted within hours — that falsely showed him calling Shri Swatantra Bhardwaj a "dimagi naxali" and "jaatiwaadi." Shri Bhatia said no such thing.

Who is the Swatantra Bhardwaj whom Shri Bhatia was falsely shown condemning? He is presently under arrest, accused of assaulting the father of a teenage student activist at a protest. He was detained after a podcast clip went viral in which he is heard boasting that he "cracked the skull" of his victim, an injury he himself put at 60 stitches, and naming the offence without any prompting from a lawyer: "Do you know which section this crime attracts? Section 307, attempt to murder." He now denies the assault, pleads self-defence, and says the clip is fake. And in a separate clip circulated on September 4, he is heard personally announcing that "Brahmin sperm is in demand around the world."

Which leaves the law with a beautiful question: whom, exactly, do the fake words defame?

Defamation needs a sting — words that lower a man in the eyes of right-thinking people. The graphic shows Shri Bhatia condemning the man just described, and distancing his party, the BJP, from him. To right-thinking people, that is not an insult. That is a testimonial. So where is the sting? The plaint must quietly assume that somewhere there is a circle of people in whose eyes disowning Bhardwaj is shameful. Which is that circle? Because the law has one firm condition: the only opinion that counts is the opinion of reasonable people. An example makes it plain. A man stabs another, intending to kill him. The victim survives. Convicted murderers in prison may sneer at the attacker for botching the job; in their eyes, the attacker stands lowered. But the law gives the opinion of convicted criminals no weight — a man's reputation is not measured by the applause of criminals. The same rule decides this suit. If the only people who would think less of Shri Bhatia for condemning Bhardwaj are people who admire what Bhardwaj is accused of doing, then their opinion counts for nothing in a court of law — and the plaint is left with no sting at all. It is left, instead, with an awkward question: which group of reasonable people thinks less of Shri Bhatia for those fake words?

Is Bhardwaj the defamed party, then? The words are about him, after all. But he has not sued — and after the record set out above, no reader needs the reason explained.

That leaves one final candidate: "dimagi naxal" itself. It is the Prime Minister's phrase — coined at the Red Fort on August 15 and applied to the wrong-thinking citizens of India, who were to be "identified and isolated." So the suit's theory must be that the Prime Minister's own vocabulary is defamation per se.

And considering what I have watched play out in defamation actions over the years, it would not be out of place for the CJP defendants to seek to summon the Hon'ble Prime Minister as a witness — the phrase is apparently his coinage, he presided at its mint, and the defendants could fairly contend that he is its best expounder, every other opinion about its meaning being speculation, in a suit that first requires the court to settle what "dimagi naxal" means. I express no view on whether such applications would succeed. I merely observe that the plaintiff has filed a plaint in which they can be seriously moved.

The matter is before the Hon'ble Court, which will decide it on law and evidence. I merely state that this is the first plaint I have read in which the plaintiff's ₹2 crore grievance is that someone put false words in his mouth — and made him look principled in the process.

K V DHANANJAYAdvocate, Supreme Court of India