> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# To the Chief Ministers of West Bengal and Tamil Nadu: Fund Legal Representation for Voters Deleted in the Special Intensive Revision
- URL: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/to-the-chief-ministers-of-west-bengal-and-tamil-nadu-fund-legal-representation-for-voters-deleted-in-the-special-intensive-revision/
- Published: 2026-04-15T04:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T06:48:15.000Z
- Description: An appeal for a State-funded legal aid scheme for citizens struck off the rolls.
- Author: K V Dhananjay
- Tags: Open Letters

**To:**

1. Smt. Mamata Banerjee, Hon'ble Chief Minister of West Bengal, Writers' Building, Kolkata – 700 001
2. Thiru M.K. Stalin, Hon'ble Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, Fort St. George, Chennai – 600 009

This is an urgent appeal to the Chief Ministers of West Bengal and Tamil Nadu to announce a State-Funded Legal Representation Scheme for citizens disenfranchised by the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, under which approximately 91 lakh voters have been deleted in West Bengal and 97 lakh in Tamil Nadu, in possible violation of Articles 14, 21, and 326 of the Constitution. The Election Commission appears intent on ensuring that those it has arbitrarily excluded are unable to vote in the upcoming State Assembly elections, having chosen to undertake this mass deletion exercise in the months immediately preceding the polls. To be unequivocally clear: this letter does not ask for the impossible task of exhausting millions of appeals before polling day next week. The ECI’s calculated timing has already ensured that tragedy. Rather, this is an appeal to ensure that every disenfranchised citizen receives appropriate, state-backed legal representation to fight their exclusion in the months and years to come, so that their erasure does not become permanent. Many of the affected voters lack the means, knowledge, and institutional support to navigate the appellate process, and the remedy, though available on paper, is illusory without legal representation. An unprecedented atrocity of this nature upon the Constitution necessarily requires lakhs of lawyers to descend upon the appellate tribunals, the High Courts, and the Supreme Court to stand behind those illegally removed. This letter proposes a binding state commitment to empanel such lawyers, at a capped fee of ₹50,000 per voter, for representation across all forums. The maximum fiscal burden of this scheme, spread over the lifetime of this litigation, does not exceed 1.71% of either state's annual revenue receipts, and a policy commitment made today stands as a lasting contribution by both Chief Ministers to the democratic architecture of their states.

Respected Chief Ministers,

I write to you in my capacity as an Advocate, and as a concerned citizen of this Republic. The matter I raise demands your immediate and decisive attention, for it goes to the very root of our democracy — the right of every citizen to vote.

## I. The Unprecedented Disenfranchisement

The facts are set out in the summary above and are not in dispute. Approximately 91 lakh electors have been removed in West Bengal, dropping the electorate from 7.6 crore to 6.7 crore — a 12 per cent decline. In Tamil Nadu, 97.37 lakh names have been deleted, reducing the electorate from 6.41 crore to 5.67 crore. Nationally, 5.18 crore names have been removed across 12 states and Union Territories, a 10.2% reduction. The scale of this exercise is without contemporary parallel in any democratic country on earth.

## II. The Thorough Illegality of the Process

The law is well-settled: once a person's name is included in the electoral roll for a previous election, that person is presumed to have been properly enrolled. The burden of displacing that presumption is heavy, and it lies squarely on the Election Commission. If the Commission has a reasonable basis to suspect that a person on the roll ought not to have been included, or that he or she no longer ought to remain on the roll by reason of death, relocation, or other disqualification, then the Commission is duty-bound to:

(a) formulate that prima facie satisfaction *in writing*; (b) issue notice to the voter concerned; (c) afford the voter a personal hearing; (d) consider the statements made during that hearing; and (e) thereafter pass a *reasoned order*.

Any order leading to exclusion is, furthermore, subject to appeal — first to the appellate tribunals, then to the High Court of the State, and ultimately to the Supreme Court of India.

Voter deletions have not been done with the care, deliberation and procedural fidelity that the law demands. Instead, the Election Commission has carried out this exercise at breakneck speed, treating the franchise of tens of millions of citizens as an administrative inconvenience to be tidied away. There is no basis whatsoever for the mass disenfranchisement of lakhs of individuals without individual notice, individual hearing, and individual orders.

The SIR process, as conducted, violates at least three provisions of the Constitution.

First, **Article 326** mandates that every citizen of India who is not less than eighteen years of age and is not otherwise disqualified on the specific grounds of non-residence, unsoundness of mind, crime, or corrupt or illegal practice, shall be entitled to be registered as a voter. Any qualification beyond these constitutional grounds is impermissible. The Election Commission's invention of categories such as "logical discrepancy" — a ground unique to West Bengal and unknown to the Constitution — amounts to the creation of a disqualification that Article 326 does not contemplate and does not permit.

Second, **Article 14** guarantees equality before the law and prohibits arbitrary state action. Mass deletion of voters without individual notice, individual hearing, and individual reasoned orders is the very class of arbitrary executive action that Article 14 was designed to prohibit. Article 14 requires that executive action that affects citizens be fair, just, and reasonable. The SIR process, as conducted, fails every one of these tests.

Third, **Article 21** guarantees that no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law — and that procedure must satisfy the requirements of natural justice, including the right to be heard. The deletion of a citizen's name from the electoral roll — which effectively deprives her of her voice in the governance of her country — is a deprivation of the gravest kind. It must be preceded by due process. The breakneck speed of the SIR has rendered that due process illusory.

What makes the illegality even more egregious is its *timing*. The Election Commission appears eager to ensure that the overwhelming majority of excluded voters are unable to vote in the upcoming State Assembly elections — elections in West Bengal scheduled for two phases on April 23 and 29, and in Tamil Nadu on April 23\. By choosing to undertake a mass and arbitrary deletion exercise *just before* a scheduled state election — in a manner that ensures those deleted cannot effectively exhaust their appeals process before polling day — the Election Commission has struck at the very heart of the constitutional design.

The Constitution of India envisaged, under Article 324, an Election Commission that would be independent, impartial, and committed to the protection of the franchise. To conduct a mass deletion of nearly two crore voters across two states in the months immediately preceding their elections — knowing full well that 34 lakh appeals in West Bengal alone cannot possibly be adjudicated before polling day, and that 19 tribunals with over one lakh cases each cannot deliver justice in the days remaining — is a complete undoing of whatever the Constitution of India wanted of independence and integrity of the Election Commission. The timing is not incidental to the injury; it *is* the injury.

## III. Why Many of the Affected Voters May Not Fight To The End

This is the most critical point of this letter, and I urge you to consider it with the gravity it deserves.

Constitutional scholars write with great enthusiasm that the right to vote is the most sacred right available to a citizen under a democracy. But between that exalted principle and the lived reality of the tens of lakhs of citizens who have been deleted from the rolls, there lies an immense and unbridgeable chasm. Many of the affected voters may not fight or fight to the end — not because they do not value their vote, but because the system assures that their fight would be very burdensome or impractical for their circumstances.

### (a) Inability to Comprehend the Process

Consider the position of the typical deleted voter. She is, in the overwhelming majority of cases, a person of modest means and limited formal education. She wakes one day to find that her name — which appeared on the electoral roll in the last election, and perhaps in every election for a decade or more — has simply vanished. She is told she must now *prove* that she belongs. She must navigate a labyrinth of procedural and documentary requirements that would confound even a practising lawyer: she must determine which form to file, before which authority, within which deadline, with which supporting documents. She must understand the distinction between an Electoral Registration Officer, a Booth Level Officer, and an Appellate Tribunal. The SIR required voters to trace their name or a parent's or relative's name to the old 2002 electoral roll as a "legacy linkage."

The assumption that ordinary citizens — daily wage earners, agricultural labourers, domestic workers, street vendors, elderly pensioners — can navigate this procedural thicket unassisted is not merely unrealistic; it is an affront to their dignity.

### (b) Fear of the Election Commission and Perception of Intimidation

The Election Commission of India is a constitutional body of immense power. It commands the apparatus of the state. It controls the rolls. It deploys Booth Level Officers who visit homes, ask questions, demand documents, and make decisions that determine whether a citizen may vote. For the ordinary citizen, the Election Commission is an authority to be feared and obeyed. The very demand for documentation, made peremptorily and without adequate notice, carries with it an implicit threat: *prove your right to belong, or be erased*.

### (c) The Prohibitive Burden of Time

Even for the citizen who understands the process and is willing to brave the system, the sheer time required to pursue a remedy is prohibitive. She must take days off from work — work that pays daily and offers no leave. She must travel to the tribunal, which may not be in her neighbourhood or even in her town. The ECI has established 19 distinct tribunals to cover the 23 districts of West Bengal, all situated at a single judicial hub at the Dr Shyama Prasad Mookherjee Institute in Kolkata. A voter in Cooch Behar or Malda must contemplate travelling hundreds of kilometres to pursue her appeal. She must attend hearings that may be adjourned, rescheduled, or delayed. And should the order go against her, she must repeat the entire exercise before the High Court, and potentially before the Supreme Court of India. For a person living on the margins, the choice between pursuing her franchise and feeding her family is no choice at all. The franchise will lose, easily.

### (d) The Mind-Numbing Pendency of Cases

Even for the voter who has the knowledge, the courage, and the time, the sheer scale of the pending cases will crush her resolve. There are 30 to 34 lakh appeals currently pending in West Bengal alone, and each tribunal has over one lakh appeals to handle. This, in a country whose judicial system is heavily burdened. In March 2026, the total number of pending cases at all levels went above 5.5 crores, including over 1,80,000 court cases pending for more than 30 years in district and high courts. March 2026 closed with 93,143 cases pending in the Supreme Court alone. According to a 2018 NITI Aayog strategy paper, at the then-prevailing rate of disposal of cases in the courts, it would take more than 324 years to clear the backlog.

The addition of 34 lakh appeals arising from the SIR in West Bengal alone — to say nothing of the lakhs that will follow in Tamil Nadu and other states — will not result in timely justice. It will result in the quiet burial of the franchise of millions. The most enthusiastic voter, the most determined citizen, the most resolute democrat will, after months of adjournments, years of waiting, and the slow erosion of hope, simply give up. Her silence will not reflect consent; it will reflect exhaustion.

## IV. The Appellate Pathway Leads Ultimately to the Supreme Court

Should the affected voters exhaust their remedies before the appellate tribunals, the law entitles them to approach the High Court of the State. And should the High Court's order be adverse, or should the High Court fail to provide timely relief, the voter retains the constitutional right to file a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court of India under Article 136 of the Constitution. In West Bengal alone, 34 lakh appeals are already pending before the tribunals.

Recently, the learned Solicitor General of India, Tushar Mehta, representing the Central Government, has urged the Supreme Court to re-examine and restrict its PIL jurisdiction. The logical corollary of the Central Government's position is this: if PILs are to be curtailed, then one must expect that each aggrieved citizen will approach the courts individually: tens of lakhs of individual petitions, each one carrying the weight of a citizen's fundamental right to vote, could flood the High Courts and the Supreme Court.

And perhaps that is precisely what democracy demands. Perhaps the gravity of what the Election Commission has done will only be felt — by the courts, by the government, and by the nation — when tens of lakhs of appeals physically reach the corridors of the High Courts and the Supreme Court. If so, then it is imperative that these appeals be filed — each one of them. And that requires lawyers.

## V. The Call to Action: A State-Funded Legal Representation Scheme and the Enlistment of the Legal Community

I am aware that every opposition party in India has, rightly, castigated the Election Commission for this travesty. But castigation alone will not restore a single voter to the rolls. What is needed now is *action* — concrete, immediate, and commensurate with the scale of the crisis.

I therefore urge both of you — as the elected Chief Ministers of the two states most grievously affected — to immediately announce a **State-Funded Legal Representation Scheme** for every citizen whose name has been improperly excluded from the electoral rolls through the SIR process. Specifically, I propose:

1. **The state shall bear the legal fees** of every affected voter who seeks to challenge her exclusion before the appellate tribunals, the High Court, and, if necessary, the Supreme Court of India.
2. **The fee per voter may be capped at ₹50,000** for full representation across all forums including the Supreme Court, and a lesser sum — say ₹25,000 to ₹30,000 — for representation that is limited to the appellate tribunal or the High Court alone.
3. **The scheme shall be open to all affected citizens** without discrimination, upon proof that their name appeared on the electoral roll for any previous election and has been unjustly deleted pursuant to the SIR.
4. **Empanelment of lawyers** across every district of the state shall be undertaken on an emergency basis, so that no voter is left without representation by reason of the unavailability of counsel.

The legal community is a great force — one of the mightiest forces in any democracy. To enlist lakhs of lawyers to fight for the constitutional rights of disenfranchised citizens would be an act of democratic mobilisation without precedent: a state-funded mobilisation of advocates, deployed not in the service of the government, but in the service of the governed. The presence of a lawyer at every stage — explaining the process, preparing the documents, appearing at hearings, filing appeals — will replace bewilderment with understanding, fear with confidence, and resignation with resistance. And critically, it will ensure that the full weight of these cases reaches the High Courts and, where necessary, the Supreme Court — so that the institutional guardians of the Constitution are confronted with the true magnitude of what has been done.

## VI. The Fiscal Burden Is Modest — A Small Price for Democracy

Let me address the obvious question: can the states afford this?

In 2025-26, Tamil Nadu has projected its revenue receipts at ₹3,31,569 crore and its GSDP at ₹35,67,818 crore. West Bengal's revenue receipts are estimated at ₹2,66,060 crore and its GSDP has crossed ₹18 lakh crore.

It must be acknowledged that a significant proportion of the deleted names are those of deceased persons, for whom no appeals will arise. In Tamil Nadu, the revision led to the deletion of 26.94 lakh names due to deaths, 66.44 lakh classified as shifted or absent, and 3.39 lakh as duplicates. The number of living voters who may need representation is therefore approximately 70.43 lakh. At the maximum cap of ₹50,000, the cost would be approximately **₹3,521 crore — just 1.06%** of Tamil Nadu's annual revenue receipts. In practice, the actual expenditure would be substantially lower.

For West Bengal, around 90.93 lakh voters were removed. More than 58 lakh names were deleted as absent, shifted, dead and duplicate voters in the initial draft stage alone. The proportion of deceased voters would similarly reduce the pool of potential claimants. Even at the absolute ceiling — if all 90.93 lakh voters were assumed to be living and claimed the full ₹50,000 — the cost would be approximately **₹4,547 crore — roughly 1.71%** of the state's annual revenue receipts. The actual figure would be considerably less.

These are not ruinous sums. When weighed against the alternative — the silent disenfranchisement of crores of citizens — the cost is negligible. **Democracy is not cheap; but losing it is infinitely more expensive.**

To put this in perspective: Tamil Nadu's budget allocates ₹3,600 crore for fare-free bus travel and ₹13,807 crore for the Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thittam scheme. These are worthy expenditures. But no welfare scheme has meaning if the citizens it serves cannot vote in an election to choose a government. The right to vote is the precondition for every other right and every other benefit.

## VII. Conclusion

The Election Commission's arbitrary mass exclusion of voters during the SIR has no parallel in the democratic world or in modern history. The process has been hasty, opaque, and carried out with a cavalier disregard for the procedural safeguards rooted in Articles 14, 21, and 326 of the Constitution. The result is that lakhs upon lakhs of Indian citizens will be unable to vote in elections that will determine the governments of their states.

And the cruelest irony is this: the very existence of a remedy on paper will be used by the Election Commission to claim that no injustice has been done. *"The remedy exists,"* they will say. *"Let the voters avail it."* But you and I know — and every honest observer of Indian public life knows — that the remedy is illusory for the overwhelming majority. The voter who cannot read the form, who cannot afford the lawyer, who cannot take the day off work, who cannot comprehend why her name was deleted, who is frightened by the very institution that deleted her, and who knows that her appeal will languish for months or years in a system drowning in over 5.5 crore pending cases — that voter has no remedy. She has only the appearance of one.

A scheme announced today by your governments would create a **binding obligation on the State** — an obligation that endures regardless of which party holds power after the elections. Even if the incumbents are voted out, the commitment to fund the legal representation of disenfranchised voters will survive the change of government. This is not merely a political gesture; it is the creation of a **lasting institutional safeguard** — a legacy that transcends the electoral cycle and outlasts the tenure of any government.

It falls to you to make the remedy real. Please announce, today, that your states will fund the legal fight of every disenfranchised voter. Enlist the legal community — the lakhs of advocates across your states — in a great democratic cause of our time. Let the message be clear: if the Election Commission will not protect the franchise, the elected governments of these states will.

The right to vote is the foundation upon which every other right in a democracy rests.

I trust that this appeal will receive the urgent consideration it deserves.