> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Karnataka May Sue the Centre for Itself, but Not for Its Panchayats. Their Court Is the High Court.
- URL: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/karnataka-may-sue-the-centre-for-itself-but-not-for-its-panchayats-their-court-is-the-high-court/
- Published: 2026-11-20T04:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T07:53:43.000Z
- Description: Whether a suit by the State under Article 131 over the Rs. 2,186.20 crore panchayat grant can proceed at all.
- Author: K V Dhananjay
- Tags: Press Releases, #bengaluru, #video

0:00 

/6:00 

1× 

A six-minute explainer of this note.

The Government of Karnataka is preparing to take the Union Government to the Supreme Court over a sum of Rs. 2,186.20 crore. This money is the grant recommended by the Fifteenth Finance Commission for the year 2025-26 for the gram panchayats of Karnataka. The Union Government has not released it, and it cites discrepancies in the State’s records of earlier transfers to the panchayats. The Minister for Rural Development and Panchayat Raj, Mr. Eshwar B. Khandre, says that other States with larger discrepancies have received their grants in full.

The Minister has spoken of filing a “Special Leave Petition”. A special leave petition is an appeal to the Supreme Court against the order of a court or tribunal, and no court or tribunal has made any order in this matter. The remedy that the State has in mind must therefore be an original suit under Article 131 of the Constitution, by which a State may sue the Union directly in the Supreme Court. This note takes no side on whether the grant has been rightly or wrongly withheld. It examines whether such a suit by the State can proceed at all.

## The picture and the provision

Most members of the public will see this dispute as a family quarrel. They will picture a mother who goes to court and tells the judge that the father has stopped providing for their child. It is a sympathetic picture, and the hardship behind it is real, because villages across the State are short of money for drinking water and for repairs.

Article 131, however, does not look at the dispute in this way. It gives the Supreme Court exclusive jurisdiction over a dispute between the Union and a State, provided that the dispute involves a question on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. The Supreme Court has held that only the Union and the States can be parties to such a suit (*State of Bihar v. Union of India*, 1970). The Court will therefore ask what the legal right is and to whom that legal right belongs.

## Three tiers of government

The Constitution today provides for government at three levels, which are the Union, the States and the local bodies. Part IX, which came into force in 1993, gives panchayats a fixed term of five years, regular elections and a claim on public finance. Article 280(3)(bb) requires the Finance Commission of the Union to recommend measures to supplement the resources of panchayats. Article 243-I requires every State to appoint its own Finance Commission for the same purpose. The Constitution has thus made the well-being of panchayats the shared responsibility of the Union and of the States.

The law made by the Karnataka Legislature goes a step further. Section 6 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 declares every grama panchayat to be a body corporate, and it gives every grama panchayat the capacity to sue and to be sued in its own name. The grant in dispute is meant for these bodies. The grant passes through the Consolidated Fund of the State, and the State is required to transfer it to the panchayats within ten working days or to pay interest for the delay.

## The question that the Supreme Court is likely to ask

The State will appear before the Supreme Court as the voice of about six thousand gram panchayats. Each of these panchayats is able to speak for itself in a court of law, although not in a suit under Article 131\. The Supreme Court is therefore likely to ask the State a simple question. What happens if some of these panchayats have a grievance against the State Government itself?

This is a real possibility. Some panchayats may say that an earlier instalment of the grant reached them late. Some may say that their share under the recommendations of the State’s own Finance Commission remains unpaid. Some may say that their elections are overdue. The Union Government may raise these very matters in its defence, because its objection rests on the State’s records of transfers to the panchayats.

In that situation, the Supreme Court would be asked to decide matters that affect panchayats which are not before it and which cannot be brought before it. The State cannot be expected to argue against itself on their behalf. It is therefore unlikely that the Supreme Court will accept the State as the representative of all panchayats when some of them may have a grievance against the State itself. The State will have to explain how its suit can proceed in spite of this difficulty.

## The objection that the Union may raise

The case of the State is that money owed to its panchayats has not reached them, and that the State is the channel through which that money must pass. The Union may answer this case with an objection of its own. It may say that the panchayats are the bodies that have been injured, that the panchayats are authorised by law to sue for themselves, and that the panchayats alone should therefore be heard on that injury.

That objection would have considerable force, although not for the reason that applies in an ordinary civil suit. Article 131 does not require a State to prove loss to itself in the way that a private plaintiff must. What it requires is a dispute between the Union and the State about a legal right. The question, therefore, is whether the State is asserting an obligation that the Union owes to the State itself, or whether it is seeking to enforce an entitlement that belongs to the panchayats.

The State has an answer available to it. The grant is released by the Union to the State and enters the Consolidated Fund of the State, and the State may say that the Union owes the State a duty to release it. If the State pleads its case in that way, the suit may well be entertained, as the decision of 1977 in its own earlier suit, which is discussed below, shows. If, however, the State comes to the Supreme Court only as the voice of its panchayats and complains of the harm that they have suffered, the position is different. In my view, a suit framed in that way is unlikely to proceed, because the harm belongs to bodies that are competent to sue for themselves and that cannot be heard in the Supreme Court.

## What earlier suits in the Supreme Court say

States have used Article 131 against the Union before. In 1977, after the Janata Party won the Lok Sabha elections, the Union Home Minister, Mr. Charan Singh, wrote to the Chief Ministers of nine States governed by the Congress and advised them to seek dissolution of their Assemblies. The Union Law Minister, Mr. Shanti Bhushan, said the same thing in a broadcast. Six States filed suits under Article 131, and a Bench of seven judges dismissed all of them (*State of Rajasthan v. Union of India*). The judges differed on whether such suits could be entertained at all, and several of them drew a line between a dispute about a legal right and a complaint that is political in nature.

In the same year, Karnataka itself went to the Supreme Court under Article 131\. In May 1977, the Union Government appointed Mr. Justice A.N. Grover, a retired judge of the Supreme Court, as a one-man Commission of Inquiry. The Commission was to inquire into charges of corruption, nepotism, favouritism and misuse of governmental power against the Chief Minister, Mr. D. Devaraj Urs, and some of his Ministers. The State Government had already appointed a commission of its own. The State sued the Union and contended that the Union had no power to order an inquiry into the conduct of the Ministers of a State.

On 8 November 1977, a Bench of seven judges dismissed the suit and upheld the appointment of the Grover Commission (*State of Karnataka v. Union of India*). The Union had objected that its notification did not affect the State as such, and that the suit was therefore not maintainable. The majority rejected that objection and gave Article 131 a broad reading. The majority held that a State need not show that its own legal right has been infringed, so long as the dispute turns on a legal right.

What happened afterwards is instructive. The Grover Commission continued its work and submitted its first report on 30 January 1978, in which it found four of the charges that it had examined to be well founded. By then Mr. Urs was out of office. He won the Assembly elections that followed, however, and returned as Chief Minister on 28 February 1978\. The Union Government sent the report to the State Government for follow-up action, which meant that the report went to a government headed by Mr. Urs himself. The final report was placed before Parliament in May 1979, and Mr. Urs remarked that the report of a commission is only a report and not a judgment. The suit under Article 131 thus settled a question of law, but it did not settle the political contest behind it.

The most recent instance is the suit filed by Kerala against the ceiling placed by the Union on its borrowing. On 1 April 2024, the Supreme Court declined to grant interim relief and referred the suit to a Bench of five judges. The Court asked that Bench to decide whether Article 293 gives a State an enforceable right to borrow, and it also referred questions on the scope of Article 131.

In July 2024, the Supreme Court rejected the preliminary objections of the Union to a suit filed by West Bengal over investigations by the Central Bureau of Investigation after the State had withdrawn its consent (*State of West Bengal v. Union of India*). The Court allowed the suit to proceed and left the merits open. That decision shows that the Court does not lightly turn a State away at the threshold when the State asserts a legal power of its own. West Bengal, however, was asserting its own power over investigations within its territory. Karnataka must first show that the right to this grant belongs to the State and not to the panchayats.

These decisions hold a lesson for both governments. The State will have to identify a legal right, because hardship alone will not sustain a suit under Article 131\. One ground available to the State is unequal treatment among States, provided that the other States were in a comparable position. The Union, for its part, cannot say that a dispute about money lies outside Article 131\. The Union will have to explain why it has not released to Karnataka a grant of the kind that it has released to other States.

## The remedy of the panchayats

The panchayats do not have to wait for either government to act. A panchayat that is aggrieved can file a writ petition under Article 226 before the High Court of Karnataka, and the Union Government is answerable to that Court. A suit filed by the State in the Supreme Court will not take away this remedy, because the panchayats will not be parties to that suit, although a ruling of the Supreme Court on the law will guide every court that hears them afterwards. The Supreme Court has held that Article 131 does not prevent those who cannot invoke it from approaching the High Court (*Tashi Delek Gaming Solutions v. State of Karnataka*, 2006).

This note does not take any side on whether the grant has been rightly or wrongly withheld. Its stand is on the question of who should go to court, and to which court. If the State sues to enforce a duty that the Union owes to the State itself, the Supreme Court may hear the suit. If the State sues as the voice of its panchayats, the suit is unlikely to cross the threshold, because the panchayats can speak for themselves and some of them may have grievances against the State itself. The grievance of a panchayat belongs to the panchayat, and the court for that grievance is the High Court of Karnataka.

[Signed PDF of this piece](https://www.kvdhananjay.in/content/files/2026/11/K-V-Dhananjay-2026-11-20-Karnataka-Panchayats-Article-131.pdf)

0:00 

/6:00 

1× 

The same explainer in upright format, for phones.