> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# In Preventing One Alleged Suicide, Is the Delhi High Court Undermining Its Own Credibility?
- URL: https://www.kvdhananjay.in/in-preventing-one-alleged-suicide-is-the-delhi-high-court-undermining-its-own-credibility/
- Published: 2026-07-20T04:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T07:53:45.000Z
- Description: Reads together the Delhi High Court's two orders on Sonam Wangchuk's fast.
- Author: K V Dhananjay
- Tags: Press Releases, #new-delhi

The Delhi High Court set out to prevent the alleged suicide of Sonam Wangchuk. Unfortunately, in the process, it appears to be undermining its own institutional credibility. Read the two orders together — the Division Bench's order of 16 July 2026 in W.P.(C) 9498/2026 on the stranger's PIL, and yesterday's order in W.P.(C) 9770/2026 on the writ petition of Mr. Wangchuk's wife — and the impression is reasonable and unavoidable.

Let it be said plainly, and first: the Delhi High Court is, by any measure, the leading High Court in this country — in the quality of its Bench, in the strength of its Bar, in the reach of its jurisprudence, and in the trust that litigants across the nation repose in it. It is precisely because of that standing that these two orders matter so much. What has just happened there is likely to raise genuine worries about public confidence in the administration of justice.

Begin with the PIL. The Central Government hates public interest litigation. It has said so, repeatedly and officially, to the Supreme Court of India — that the PIL jurisdiction is abused, that self-appointed crusaders clog the courts, that busybodies must be shown the door. Now watch what happened in the Delhi High Court. A stranger, appearing in person, filed a PIL expressing "concern about the health condition" of Mr. Wangchuk. Understand the setting: Sonam Wangchuk was not fasting on the summit of Mount Everest, stranded and ailing, beyond the reach of family and physician, where State intervention would be the only conceivable rescue. He was fasting in the heart of Jantar Mantar — the most watched protest site in the country — surrounded by his followers and other protestors, attended by his own doctors, monitored daily; a man, moreover, who has previously - reportedly - withstood fasts of thirty and thirty-five days. What outside help did he need? What was the "public interest" vacuum that only a stranger's petition could fill? If a PIL had to be filed at all, one asking the Delhi High Court to direct Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan to step down would at least have made moral sense — though it would have been legally impermissible, for no court can direct a Minister's resignation. Between that impermissible petition and the one actually filed, the impermissible one had more sense in it.

And here is the marvel: the Central Government, allergic to PILs everywhere else, dropped its allergy at the door of this one. It did not ask that the busybody be shown the exit. Far from opposing the petition, the Central Government volunteered assurances: daily monitoring by Government doctors, and "whatever medical intervention/steps are needed." The Court recorded its appreciation of the stance so taken by the Central Government, converted the assurance into a direction, and disposed of the petition the same day. Now notice who is missing from this proceeding: Sonam Wangchuk. The one human being whose body was the subject matter of the order was not a party, was not served, and was not heard. Yet within two days, the order was brandished as the warrant on which policemen lifted a conscious, protesting citizen onto a stretcher at dawn and carried his protest away with him. One does not need a Ph.D. in legal jurisprudence to see how awkward this is. Mr. Wangchuk was protesting against this very Central Government; if there was one thing he demonstrably did not want, it was the police answerable to that Government forcibly removing him from his protest in the name of caring for him. A jurisdiction meant to protect the citizen against the State was thus placed at the service of the State against the citizen — on the motion of a stranger.

Now to yesterday's order. See what it does. It accepts that Mr. Wangchuk is a free citizen and not in detention. It accepts that he is conscious and of sound mind — nobody before the Court suggested otherwise. It records that the doctors withheld IV fluids because he did not consent to them, and that everything actually given to him was given with his consent. So everyone in that courtroom — the Government, the doctors, the Court — proceeded on the footing that his consent matters and that he is fully capable of giving or refusing it.

And then the order forgets all of this. He never consented to being lifted from Jantar Mantar. He never consented to Safdarjung Hospital. The order's answer is that since he did not check himself into any hospital on his own volition, the Government came under a "bounden duty" to put him in one. So his "no" to a needle is honoured, while his "no" to the hospital itself is overruled — by the same order, on the same day, about the same man. If he is competent to refuse the drip, he must be competent to refuse the ward. On the order's logic, a citizen's right to say "no" somehow survives even after every "no" that mattered has been overruled — his "no" to being lifted and removed from his protest site, his "no" to a hospital he never chose, his "no" to a Medical Team he never engaged. So long as his later "no" to some particular needle is graciously honoured, the Court will accept that as proof that his bodily autonomy is respected.

The Court says he is free and not detained — yet when his family asked to shift him to Medanta Hospital, offering to keep the very same AIIMS and Safdarjung doctors associated with his treatment there, even that was refused. A free man can be moved by his family to a hospital they trust; only a detained man cannot. It then records, as though it were generosity, that his family has been given "unprecedented" access to him — but a man to whom his family is "given access" is, in ordinary usage, in custody. And notice, finally, that everything needed to save his life was available at Medanta too. The only thing not available at Medanta was Central Government control.

The two orders share a common intention and a common irony. Both mean to prevent Sonam Wangchuk from allegedly committing suicide. Both, in their operation, appear — unfortunately — to undermine the credibility of the Delhi High Court — a slow, institutional kind of injury, in which a constitutional court, established to stand between the citizen and the State, becomes instead the corridor through which the State has marched here to disrupt a peaceful fast. There is still time to turn back.

[Signed PDF of this piece](https://www.kvdhananjay.in/content/files/2026/11/K-V-Dhananjay-2026-07-20-Delhi-High-Court-and-Sonam-Wangchuk.pdf)